A guide to green fee value for money

Category: James Braid (Page 10 of 10)

17. Scotscraig. 23rd May 2015

Great links worth the visit if you’re also playing St Andrews 

Summary:  Midweek £65 (round); £85 (day); weekend (morning) £80.   Par 71.  Value (out of 5) – 3.5

Detail: 

Scotscraig 18th green and clubhouse

Scotscraig 18th green and clubhouse

Scotscraig was founded in 1817 by some members of the St. Andrews Society of Golfers (later to be the R&A) and therefore became the 13th Golf Club in the world.   Pedigree apart, it’s a great test of golf and has been  a final qualifying venue many times when The Open has been at St Andrews.  It has therefore played host to many of the world’s best golfers.

 

It is a fine links course, but with a layout more typical of a parkland course, therefore wind direction impacts differently on each hole, unlike many of the “out and back” links courses on the east of Scotland. 

Par 3 6th at Scotscraig

Par 3 6th at Scotscraig

Scotscraig also has a fair number of trees as well.  This, coupled with a lot of broom, the indigenous Scottish links shrub, makes for a really nice vista on many of the holes.

The greens had recently been rotavated and treated by the newly appointed green keeper, and so were not typical of the good condition that I’d experienced here several times before – however, the rest of the course was in excellent condition.

Approach to the 7th at Scotscraig

Approach to the 7th at Scotscraig

Playing with an old family friend, David Husband, a member of Scotscraig for many years, I was reminded of the importance of local knowledge to playing links courses, especially when the ground around the greens becomes so hard, and the need to play the chip and run, sometimes from up to 100 yards out.  Even if you’re not used to this form of the game, its nice to try this shot out.

There are some great holes at Scotscraig, with the par 4 fourth hole, stroke index 1, being the first major test, played to a steep sided plateau green, over a second shot carry from the fairway – settle for a bogey and move on.  You also need to be aware from several of the tees of the adjacent greens and tees which criss-cross at times.

The par 3 15th with Moly's best shot of the day!

The par 3 15th with Moly’s best shot of the day!

There are also 2 really nice mid iron par 3s, the 6th and 15th, the latter to a 2 tier green would be a good “nearest the pin” for a society.

I had a mixed round, with 55 out and 45 home, the latter with an 8, but enough to win my match – but to be fair neither David nor I played to our handicap, on a day when the wind got up sufficiently to make scoring difficult.

A nice club house with good visitor facilities make this course well worth a visit.

Key Facts

Course Type: Links

Green Fees:  

Midweek £65 round  £85 day
Weekend £80 (morning)

Par 71 (3 par 5, 11 par 4s, 4 par 3s)

Distance(yellow)  6310  yards

Moly’s Gross score100

Moly's Scotscraig scorecard - 100

Moly’s Scotscraig scorecard – 100

8. Dalmahoy East; 30th July 2014

Wide fairways, but avoid the bunkers to score well.

Summary:  Cost £65 (midweek).  Par 73.  Score 96.  Value (out of 5) – 2.  

Outstanding view of Edinburgh Castle from the 16th hole

Outstanding view of Edinburgh Castle from the 16th hole

Detail. Marriot Hotels run the Dalmahoy Hotel, Golf and Country Club, which is on the South East of Edinburgh about a 10 minute drive from Edinburgh Airport.   The resort has 2 courses; the East course is a championship layout designed by James Braid and hosted the Solheim Cup in 1992, the West course is a much shorter later addition.

 

Moly and Andy in front of Estate house adjacent the 18th green.

Moly and Andy adjacent to the 18th green.

This was my first 18 holes played since a back injury in early March, so quite a special day, especially accompanied by my son, Andy, who plays off 17.   Despite never being up, I came back from 4 down at the 10th to halve the game;  I was 9 over par after 3 holes, having found the sand in very good condition!

Dalmahoy East is a nice, but quite repetitive course, with many holes feeling much the same – i.e. straight, generous fairway, no carry hazard, trees with limited impact, very light rough, well positioned fairway/greenside bunkers, true and flat-ish green.  There was only one real dog-leg, the 9th.  It is surprisingly accessible to higher handicap golfers playing from the yellow tees, which takes 650 yards off the championship length.

Approach to the 9th over the country house "ha ha" wall, the most picturesque hole

Approach to the 9th over the country house “ha ha” wall, the most picturesque hole

The warm summer had also taken its toll when we played, with several parts of the fairway being brown and a couple of the greens were very dry.  However, one can imagine the course a different challenge when wet and playing its full length.

At £65 for a weekday round and £75 for a weekend round, I had expected a bit more conditioning and challenge, and I would strongly recommend seeking to play using a voucher if available, otherwise you might be disappointed.  We used a Golfcare insurance voucher which made it good value.

Andy teeing to the 17th, "the wee wrecker"

Andy teeing to the 17th, “the wee wrecker”

With a good group discount this would make a good venue for society days, as the Marriot has great changing and eating facilities.

Key Facts

Course Type: Parkland

Green Fees: 

Summer Weekday, £65 per round;  Weekend, £75.

Par 73 (4 par 5s, 11 par 4s, 3 par 3s)

Distance(yellow): 6684 yards

Moly’s Gross score: 96.  (9 over for first 3 holes; 14 over for other 15 holes!)

Dalmahoy Scorecard - a disastrous start!

Dalmahoy Scorecard – a disastrous start!

 

7. Blairgowrie “Wee” 9 hole; Wed 8th Jan 2014

Avoid Wednesdays and Saturdays!

Summary:  Cost £10 (winter).  Par 32.  Score 43.  Value (out of 5) – 3.5.      

Detail.   Blairgowrie has a population of 8000, it has some quaint but dated shops, certainly no high street coffee branded shops here.   It does however have a fine golf club with 3 courses, 2 of which are listed amongst the very best in the world, laid out by the renowned James Braid!   Blairgowrie epitomises the wonderful conundrum of Scottish golf.

The weather looked good and I set off after being advised during a quick telephone call that the Lansdowne course was free for several tee times around mid-day.   However, as it turns out, Wednesday and Saturday are the days traditionally the members play en mas, and when I arrived the tee times were taken.  I therefore settled for playing the Wee Course, and it turned out fine.  But the message for visitors is avoid Wednesdays and Saturdays.

“The Wee”, is a lovely little 9 hole course (5 par 4s, and 3 par 3s), with ample lush fairways (they get their fair share of rain in Blairgowrie!) set in very mature woodland.  Other than the 416 yard 8th, the par 4s are short and require accuracy, not length, from the tees, especially as some are dog legs where a driver will out-run of fairway.  The bunkers have soft sand and were well raked, and the greens were big for a 9 hole layout.

The 2nd hole, a dog leg right, has a green protected by 2 magnificent trees making the approach an interesting challenge.  Much easier to play in winter with less leaves!

2 trees guarding the 2nd green

2 trees guarding the 2nd green

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

However, the most intriguing hole was the par 3 7th, where you must trust your yardage as there is an unseen valley full of bunkers in front of the green.

Hidden Greens in front of 7th green

Hidden Greens in front of 7th green

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I had a disaster on the par 3 4th, where I pulled both tee shots well left, and ended with a 7.  That actually sums up Blairgowrie – stay out of the trees to have any chance of scoring well.  I look forward to tackling the Rosemount and Lansdowne courses, both championship quality.

News of the Day:  Dennis Rodman, the US former basketball player, has apologised for angry comments he made about a US man detained in North Korea. Rodman is the most high-profile American to meet the young North Korean leader Kim Jong-un , who he describes as a friend.  Bizarre!

Key Facts

Course Type: Heathland

Green Fees: 

May – Sep;  £30.00 per day;   Winter £10 for 9, or £15 for 18.

Par 32 (5 par 4s, 4 par 3s)

Distance2373 yards

Moly’s Gross score: 43

Blairgowrie "Wee" scorecard

Blairgowrie “Wee” scorecard

5. Lundin Ladies 9 hole; 26th Dec 2013

Get past the Ladies Tee on this course!

Clubhouse and 9th Green

Clubhouse and 9th Green

Lundin Ladies is the oldest all-female members club in the world, and as such deserves a visit for its place in golfing history.  Interestingly, I don’t think it picks up quite as much criticism though for it’s single sex membership rules as does The Honourable Company of Edinburgh Golfers at Muirfield does.  Then again, Muirfield doesn’t have an honestly box!

In many ways Lundin Ladies is a quintessential Scottish small course, typical of the type often found in the Scottish Highlands;  9 holes, small clubhouse with external toilet, and honesty box beside the starter.  131226_Lundin Ladies 6th teeAs a womens club, the “back tees”, are the LGU Red tees, with the white tees being in front, therefore this is one of the few courses where my tee shots were guaranteed to land in front of the ladies tee!

It’s course signature is 3 standing stones set on the 2nd fairway, which also has a well positioned bunker down the right side, designed for a tee shot aimed to the right of the stones.

Standing Stones on the 2nd hole - an interesting hazard!

Standing Stones on the 2nd hole – an interesting hazard!

However, the ideal line is directly over the stones, as a good drive should clear the stones comfortably.

The course is relatively straight forward, with the first 4 holes, all par 4s, having wide fairways with accessible greens, albeit the 3rd (stroke index 1) is played uphill and the approach shot needs a club selection at least 1-2 clubs longer (advice I’m afraid I didn’t follow!).

Views from Lundin Links

Views from Lundin Links

Although near to the Fife coast there are no sea views, however this is made up for by some nice countryside views inland.

7th Teeing area

7th Teeing area

 

 

 

 

The 7th hole, a par 4, but really a long par 3 for men, is the most picturesque hole, with a long carry to a raised green.

With the right wind conditions, some of the par 4s are within range for the longer hitters;  I actually reached the green on the 8th – the wind must have got up at that point!

 

I had a disastrous first 5 holes, 3 putting 2 greens and going out of bounds with a hook of the par 4 third hole.  Luckily I played the last 4 in around par to  save my card.

A nice course, well worth playing for its historical place in the history of golf.  I’ll need to go back for those first 5 holes 🙂

Key Facts

Course Type: Parkland

Green Fees:  18 Holes £16.00;  9 Holes £10.00

Par 34 (7 par 4s, 2 par 3s)

Distance2365 yards

Moly’s Gross score: 44

Lundin Ladies scorecard

Lundin Ladies scorecard

Newer posts »

© 2026 Scotland Golf Bible

Theme by Anders NorenUp ↑