Promised a Sunningdale, Aberdeen sacked MacKenzie, let the Parks Department finish the job, then named the course after him. At times, truth is beautiful.
Price Paid: £15 (GolfNow; list price £30 in 2023)
Current Price (2026): £35.60 summer list; £17.80 twilight; £22 winter list; £25 GolfNow (winter)
Value Rating: 5/5 at £15 / 5/5 at £25 current GolfNow / 4.5/5 at £35.60 summer list
Moly’s Score: 99 gross; net 84; 24 Stableford points (playing handicap 15)

The MacKenzie Championship Course sits in Hazlehead Park, about four miles west of the city centre in the Aberdeen City council area. In 1319 Robert the Bruce feued the royal Stocket Forest, Hazlehead included, to the burgh. From 1551 the town feued it out in turn, and the land drifted into private estates before the council bought Hazlehead back in 1920 for £40,000. Then it hired the finest golf architect alive and fell out with him.

I covered MacKenzie the man in Pitreavie (Blog 150): the camouflage, the principles, the “dead ground”. His Hazlehead story is much less flattering. He started advising the council in 1922 and told them to expect something like Sunningdale, on a budget of £8,000. By the summer of 1926 the project was late and over budget, due to unforeseen ground conditions, and MacKenzie was venting at the council in the Press and Journal and offering to finish the job for nothing.

The council declined and paid him off. Only ten of his holes had been built. The Links and Parks Superintendent, a Mr Clark, was told to finish the rest as cheaply and as quickly as possible, and he laid them out in the open meadows beside the wood. The course opened in July 1927, two years late and about £10,000 over budget. Some 5,000 people watched J.H. Taylor play the exhibition match. The Lord Provost’s speech didn’t mention MacKenzie, who stayed away.

Eighty-eight years later, in 2015, the council renamed its No 1 course in his honour, and the course turns 100 in 2027. Sport Aberdeen now says the course “still retains the architect’s basic design”. “Basic” is doing a lot of work in that sentence.

So what did I find? The woodland holes are genuinely good. The greens are very large and were in good condition, and the bunkering is economical: usually one dominant greenside bunker rather than a scattering. Among the pines I kept thinking of Blairgowrie’s Rosemount (Blog 176), where MacKenzie also had a hand, and Ladybank (Blog 160). But much of the course is flat, and the holes have less variety than the name on the sign leads you to expect. Now I know why: that’s what meadow golf on a council budget looks like. The tees and some of the bunkers could be better too.

I partnered Fran and I played very poorly. The shank made an appearance, three balls were lost, and those enormous greens extracted four three-putts. The 6th and 7th, two of the hardest holes on the front nine, cost me two snowmen. Final tally: 99 gross and 24 points.
Colin Nelson, the PGA professional at Hazlehead, told me the Golf Aberdeen membership was “the best value golf in the world”. He’d never heard of South Ayrshire’s season ticket, so I did the comparison for him. In 2023 the five-day senior subscription was £19 a month. Today the five-day adult ticket is £27.50 a month (£330 a year) for five courses, with 25% off for Aberdeen residents of state pension age. Golf South Ayrshire’s five-day ticket for 2026/27 costs £495 for eight courses. “The world” is beyond my research budget, but within Scotland Colin may well be right.

Does it matter that MacKenzie didn’t finish the job? To the golf, less than you’d think: a good hole is a good hole, whoever drew it. To our perception of it, it matters a great deal. Put “MacKenzie” on the sign and we arrive expecting a masterpiece, and too often we find one, because we were told to. I’m no different: I walked those pine-lined holes thinking of Blairgowrie. We’re all sheep at times.

Strip away the myth and this is a good council parkland course: ten holes with a famous pedigree, eight of municipal thrift, and fine greens throughout. At £15 that’s 5/5 value. GolfNow’s £25 winter rate still earns 5/5, though the council’s own winter fee is £22, so for once it pays to book direct. The £35.60 summer rate is 4.5/5, and the £17.80 twilight rate is a steal. Would I go back? Yes, with fewer shanks, and without the halo.
Facts:
Course Type: Parkland (woodland)
Par: 70 (2 par 5s, 12 par 4s, 4 par 3s)
Distance: 5,963 yards (yellow tees)
Course Rating / Slope: 69.3 / 124
Course Quality: 4/5
Moly’s Gross Score: 99
