A guide to green fee value for money

Category: 4 star (Page 2 of 12)

186. Broadlees Par 3. 25 Mar 2023

Scotland’s first synthetic greens course, probably.

Price: £8. Par 27. Value: 4/5.

Moly’s Score: 31 (+4)

The backstory is in Blog 185, the main Broadlees course. In summary, since 2004, Robert and Barbara Anderson have built a diverse golf operation – range, 9-hole course, crazy golf, footgolf, academy, café and Santa’s grotto – to compete in an area stocked with golfing alternatives, many of them subsidised.

In 2021, they added something possibly unique in Scotland: a 9-hole par 3 course with synthetic greens and tees, playable every day of the year regardless of weather or ground conditions. The commercial reasoning is sound: a course needing no greenkeeping on its playing surfaces, generating income in January.

The first (97 yards) with the startlingly green synthetic surface immediately apparent against the March gloom. You are not playing a normal golf course.

From the start the scene is stripped back entirely with open ground, single windswept tree, and a synthetic “green” looking like a piece of discarded carpet. Not aesthetic, but very interesting, with the graves of golfing Architects stirring?

Synthetic tees matter commercially as much as the greens, as grass par 3 tees are brutally punished and need constant repair, reseeding, levelling and divot mix. The cost of upkeep of mats is negligible, plus they play consistently.

Hole 3 from elevated tee. The two wind turbines are a constant presence.

Holes range from 85 to 138 yards, so this is great wedge practice. They are not architecturally interesting in any way. But the holes have several water hazards to contend with.

The fourth green with synthetic pile; dense, uniform with its own playing logic.

The key question is “how do the greens play?”. The answer is situational. In wet March conditions the green surrounds were too soft for a chip and run approach. The only option was to fly the ball onto the front of the green and allow it to release. The surface bounces more than ‘checks’ on full shots, so that requires careful judgment. Land too deep into the green and the ball runs through; land short and it stops on wet grass short.

Short chips around the green, played softly, were a different matter — the synthetic pile had enough give to generate some check, certainly more than expected. A useful discovery, though it came too late on the card to rescue early bogeys. On the greens themselves the ball rolled true, although breaking differently from a grass surface.

The 9th (91 yards), looking towards the Broadlees clubhouse, with cafe, range, and main course off to the right.

I shot 31 gross, four over par. On the two holes where I holed from outside ten feet I correctly read that the ball would not break as much as expected. It was an education. I’m sure regular players hole lots of putts.

At £8 for nine holes (2023) this is great ‘novelty’ value. I would think there is a commercial opportunity to price a combined fee with 9 holes on this course and 9 holes on the main Broadlees course.

Value: 4/5, to play Scotland’s first and possibly only synthetic greens course

Facts:

Course type: Par 3, synthetic tees and greens

Par 27 . Distance: 972 yards.

Moly’s Gross Score: 31 (+4)

See also: Blog 185 — Broadlees Golf Course

180. Hilton Park. 21 Mar 23.

Ewan Grimes – What a Pro!

Value – 4/5

Golf in Scotland is a competitive market, so a friendly welcome is essential. Ewan Grimes, the recently appointed pro at Hilton Park, could not have been more hospitable to me. It made up for the miserably wet weather and golf course, which arguably should have been closed. At least that meant it was very quiet and took less than 3 hours to play.

The 17th at Hilton Park, a par 3 of 184 yards with common white and yellow tees.

Hilton Park, just outside Milngavie, is about 10 miles north of Glasgow City Centre, but feels much more remote. It is one of only 23 clubs in Scotland that has two or more 18 hole courses. Moreover, it is one of only 3 clubs with two heathland courses, the others being Gleneagles and Blairgowrie.

Moly putting on the 6th, the most difficult of the four par 3s.

I played both the Hilton Park and Allander courses in one day, which was a challenge given the undulating terrain. A buggy might be useful here. There are excellent views, including of the Glasgow skyline, something made easier by the loss of many trees in recent years due to storms.

The Hilton Park layout was much more demanding that its sister Allander course, but as a combination of courses they compliment each other really well.

The well bunkered par three 12th hole, the stroke index 18 hole.

The course routing was a little confusing and I ended up playing the 15th hole twice, having also played some of the Allander holes in the wrong order. I suspect the reason was the shortened winter course. It was so wet, I was the only player.

The 18th is a strong finish at this undulating course.

Sadly, winter greens were in operation on the majority of holes, but I was only charged £30 for both rounds via Golfnow, which was excellent value. Overall, the Hilton Park property is one of the best in Scotland, and worth checking out.

The par four 13th, at well over 400 yards, will play as a 5 for most.

I could really imagine being a member at Hilton Park as the overall package is incredible value. It would make for a great society day out.

Views of Glasgow from the 8th, a short par 4, Moly’s only birdie hole.

Price £45.

Discount: Golf Now, £15, against the Winter rate of £30.

Course Type: Heathland

Par 70 (2 par 5s, 11 par 4s, 5 par 3s)

Distance:5446 (yellow)

Course Rating / Slope Rating (yellow) 67/127.

Moly’s Gross score: 85

Moly’s Hilton Park Scorecard, using mostly winter greens – 84

178. Hollandbush. 20 Mar 23.

Tough South Lanarkshire Council course in perennial danger of closing

Value – 4/5

Hollandbush Golf Club near Lesmahagow was founded in 1955 as a 9 hole course, later extended to 18 in 1963. Web searching “Hollandbush GC future” though will return articles about council funding woes; it’s highly likely this blog becomes redundant in future after the course closes. This will be a great shame, as Hollandbush represents a great example of a Scottish municipal course.

The free course planner, a surprising addition at this municipal course, worth playing

South Lanarkshire council operates 6 courses, in addition to Hollandbush, the other 18 holes layouts are Biggar, Langlands and Torrance House, plus two nine hole courses of Larkhall and Strathclyde Country Park.

The 17th at Hollandbush, a drivable par four, but with well positioned protective ditches

Hollandbush also has an independent golf club, providing members with competition and social benefits. This is a common feature of municipal courses in Scotland. This ‘club’ costs £115 annually.

The well maintained ditches shown here at the difficult par 4 12th hole.

Golf pricing is interesting. Annual golf membership for one of South Lanarkshire’s 18 hole municipals is £475, but for just £32 more you can play all 6 courses for £508. If you can make sense of that price differential, good luck! A green fee in peak season is £25, but the winter senior rate I paid was only £9, incredible value.

The 14th at Hollandbush, with one of the relatively few bunkers at this course.

The course is well designed; with constant changes of direction, the undulating fairways, regularly interspersed with well maintained ditches, provide a tough challenge. The slope rating of 129 from the yellow tees testifies to that, albeit it was a fairly generous course from the tee.

The greens were good at this municipal course, here seen at the 10th hole, a long par 3, one of the best holes on the course.

The course was well presented, especially given the wet conditions. I saw no-one else playing and the car park had only one other car, possibly owned by the clubhouse attendant. I think the council could reasonably consider “honesty” box payment to reduce its costs.

The second was one of several card wreckers at this well designed golf course.

I played pretty well, scoring 88, but with 4 blobs. I actually beat the course ‘1 up’, something which is a good measure of your game,

As to the name ‘Hollandbush’ it remains a mystery for me despite my efforts to find it’s origin.

It’s worth playing Hollandbush, a course I hope continues operating.

Price £25.

Discount: Senior winter rate. £9

Course Type: Parkland

Par 70 (1 par 5, 14 par 4s, 3 par 3s)

Distance: 5552 (yellow)

Course Rating / Slope Rating (yellow) 67.8/129.

Moly’s Gross score: 88

176. Blairgowrie Rosemount. 1 Dec 22.

One of the great clubs and excellent value in Winter

Value 3.5/5

Blairgowrie’s Pro explained many members lived quite far from the club, meaning competition days, Wednesday and Saturday, were incredibly busy. Therefore, playing Rosemount on the first Thursday in December, I anticipated a fast round, before finding myself behind one of those 4-balls – you know the kind – those avoiding eye contact!

The 5th, a typical tree lined hole on Rosemount. I was stuck behind a four ball, that steadfastly refused to acknowledge me. They were the rudest golfers I have ever encountered and did nothing to make Blairgowrie feel a welcome place for visitors.

Blairgowrie, or more correctly ‘Blairgowrie and Rattray’, is a twin burgh in eastern Perthshire, and a popular gateway town to the highlands. With a population of 9000, it has some quaint but dated shops.   It also has a fine golf club with 3 courses, 2 of which are listed amongst the very best in the UK.

The impressive Blairgowrie clubhouse behind the difficult 400 yards plus 18th on Rosemount.

The Rosemount course (originally called the Lansdowne) is regarded by many as the jewel in the Blairgowrie crown; designed by the Yorkshireman, Dr Alister MacKenzie, in the 1920s, with further developments by James Braid and Donald Steele. Blairgowrie’s newer 18 hole course, with the inherited Lansdowne name, was designed in the 1970s by Peter Alliss and Dave Thomas. Both courses have been further updated by Scottish Designer, Graeme Webster.

The strong 17th hole, a par 3 of 163 yards; although not as “Plateau’d” as the holes name would suggest. Easy to three putt on this very large green.

‘Lansdowne’, was in fact the original name of the current 9 hole ‘Wee Course’, blogged here. This was the founding 1889 course at Blairgowrie, named after the Dowager Marchioness of Lansdowne, a local aristocrat. It is often cited as one of the best 9 hole courses in Scotland.

The 11th tee, a typical tee shot at this course, so much so I can understand why it could be considered monotonous.

The two main18 hole layouts are championship standard and the Rosemount course hosted the European Tour in the 1970s and 1980s. It was the venue of Greg Norman’s first European tour victory in 1977 with The Martini International on 11 under par with the South African Simon Hobday in second place.

The wonderful bunkering at Rosemount, seen here at the 2nd, a short par 4 of 340 yards, and one of the good birdie chances.

Set in a large tree encrusted heathland property the courses are easy walking, and more forgiving off the tee than what meets the eye. Many of the holes feel similar and with the forested surrounds, there are limited views. Depending on the time of year, this landscape could even feel like California or Portugal.

The course is a highly attractive amateur Open venue due to the ever increasing summer green fees, which are now £140 (2023), whereas the Winter fees are less than £40. Although I played off mats and forward tees, the greens were in play. Given the greens are part of the magnificence of the course, this represents excellent Winter value golf.

The 15th “Wee Dunt”, a lyrical, and potential ryme, for this tricky par 3.

I played very well, scoring 81, and therefore I may have to thank the four ball that slowed me down. Maybe that’s the secret – taking time and concentrating.

In summary, if you are looking for a golf course that combines history, beauty, and challenge, then you might want to visit Rosemount in Blairgowrie. Especially on a nice winter’s day.

Round List Price £140. Actual Paid £30 (Winter rate).

Moly’s Score – 81 for 37 points (off 14)

Course/Slope Rating (winter) 68.8/121

Course Type: Heathland

Par 68  (14 par 4s, 4 par 3s)

Distance (yellow): c 5500 yards

Moly’s 81 on Rosemount off their winter tees, but full greens
« Older posts Newer posts »

© 2026 Scotland Golf Bible

Theme by Anders Noren — Up ↑