Scotland Golf Bible

A guide to green fee value for money

Category: 4 star (Page 1 of 11)

196. Girvan.1 May 23.

October 25, 2026 /

Is this where the Girvan Gang played?

Price Paid – £15 (GolfNow)
Current Price – £24 list (2026); £17 GolfNow
Value – 4/5 at £15 / [GolfNow tbc] / 3.5/5 at £24
Moly’s Score – 81 gross (31 Stableford points)

Moly off the 5th tee, aiming straight at Ailsa Craig. 171 yards of links, and the wind decides the club.

In my Turnberry Ailsa blog (Blog 188) I introduced the Girvan Gang. In a letter of 1751 they appear as a gaggle of lairds, a minister and a doctor playing golf at Girvan, with Sir John adjudicating both the golf and the drinking. That was three years before the St Andrews golfers formed their Society. So where did they play?

Nobody wrote it down. In a town of about a thousand souls there were only two candidates: the town green, now Stair Park and rows of Victorian villas, or the shore north of the river, where holes one to eight run today. My money is on the shore. If I’m right, Girvan’s first eight holes may be the oldest golfing ground still in play in Ayrshire.

Moly on the 1st tee, off the whites. Firth on the left, Arran on the horizon, and the old shore turf ahead.

The documented story is just as good. In 1892 Girvan’s golfers held an open-air meeting on the ruins of Turnberry Castle and formed a club to play the Turnberry links. Nine years later, when their nine-hole course north of the river was sold for villas, they moved there. Turnberry, in effect, was founded by Girvan. But Turnberry was five miles away and too far for winter golf. So in 1903 the town leased 40 acres of shore, and David Kinnell of Prestwick St Nicholas laid out nine holes on it. He thought them the finest of their size. Directories still credit James Braid. I can find no evidence he did anything here.

Fran off the 2nd, Arran across the water.

The Course

The eight links holes are a delight: firm, rumpled and wind-blown, with a run of brutal par 3s. From the whites, the 3rd is 220 yards, the 7th is 215 and the 8th is 243. It’s the kind of small, magical links that could stand beside Shiskine on Arran, the sort you’d travel just to play.

Ailsa Craig wearing its cloud cap behind the 5th green. Golf has been played on this shore since at least 1891, a decade before Turnberry existed.

Then you cross the road. In 1911 the members, wanting to “remove the congestion”, took a field along the river and extended to 18 holes. The council took the course over in the 1920s and bought it outright in 1926 for £3,000. So the council didn’t make the parkland, but it has had a century to put things right and hasn’t. Of those ten inland holes, two are good, maybe three if you’re generous to the 18th. The rest are flat field golf with a river attached, and the backdrop changes from Ailsa Craig to William Grant’s grain distillery, the Girvan end of the family that gives the world Glenfiddich and, from these very stills, Hendrick’s gin.

Looking back from the 8th tee along the old raised beach. In 1903 the papers praised the “range of hills” sheltering the course. The town Kinnell’s golfers walked from sits at the far end.
The 16th green, under the gaze of Hendrick’s gin. From Ailsa Craig to the distillery in eight holes.

In fairness, the bunkering is excellent throughout, and the island bunker at the 12th is genuinely handsome.

Something worth photographing on the inland half: the island bunker at the 12th.

The Oddities

The clubhouse sits on the road between the two halves, the starter’s hut sits somewhere else, and the starter was the grumpiest I’ve met in a while. On a municipal course, the person at the hut is the welcome. Get that wrong and nothing else recovers it.

The tee colours run white, red, yellow, with yellow as the shortest set for everyone. The stroke indices differ between tees: the 15th is SI 1 off white and SI 7 off red. Fran spotted the yellows were the forward tees and played them, so she got the shortest yardage but ladies’ par 65, with the long par 3s staying par 3s.

Girvan’s handicap board: white, red, yellow, in that order. Visitors, take note.

The Missed Opportunity

The practice green beside the starter’s box looks very much like an old 9th. Behind it, nearer the town, there’s a strip of land that could make Girvan a proper nine-hole links. How many Scottish towns have swapped a brilliant nine for a mediocre 18? Girvan is the clearest case I’ve seen. The council could give the town its links back, the ground where the Girvan Gang may have played, untouched and uncrafted. It hasn’t.

The Verdict

At £15 on GolfNow, 4/5: the front eight alone are worth it. At £24, 3.5/5. Would I go back? For the front eight, gladly.

Facts:
Course Type: Links (holes 1–8) / Parkland (9–18)
Par: 64 (no par 5s, 10 par 4s, 8 par 3s)
Distance: 5,086 yards (white)
Course Rating / Slope: 64.5 / 105
Course Quality: 3/5
Moly’s Gross Score: 81 (net 69, 31 Stableford)

Moly’s scorecard, gross 81

195. Troon Links (Fullarton). 30 Apr 23.

October 25, 2026 /

The junior course, priced like one. Usually.

Price Paid: £19.99 (GolfNow)
Current Price (2026): £28 list; GolfNow £23.99–£25.99 (October)
Value Rating: 4/5 at £19.99 / 4/5 at current GolfNow / 3.5/5 at list
Moly’s Score: 80 gross, 33 Stableford points

The 4th from the yellow tees, a 300-yard corridor of whin, heather and Scots pine; Fullarton in a single frame.

The day before, I played Lochgreen (Blog 194) for £19.99 on GolfNow. The next afternoon, I played Fullarton for £19.99 on GolfNow. Same clubhouse, same starter, same price.

They are not the same course. Lochgreen is 6,473 yards from the yellows, par 74, and was an Open qualifying course for forty years. Fullarton is 4,724 yards, par 66, with six par 3s and not a single par 5 on the men’s card. I assumed the council had simply priced all three alike. I was wrong, and it is worth explaining why.

Golf South Ayrshire’s list price for Fullarton is £28, against £38 for Lochgreen and Darley. That isn’t a rate per yard. Plenty of courses under 5,000 yards are worth far more than £28, and charge it. It is a ranking: Fullarton is the junior course of the three, and it is priced as one. On the quality of what’s here, that’s about right. The current GolfNow rates keep a similar gap. In April 2023, though, the discount algorithm briefly priced Lochgreen and Fullarton the same. On that weekend, the bargain was next door.

The 7th green and the reason for my 6. One of Fullarton’s few bunkers, and I found it.

Fullarton is a nice little course, routed through whin and pine. The bunkering is minimal and the greens are very small, so the defence is accuracy rather than sand. Miss a small green and you are chipping from tight turf. Miss the fairway and you are in the whin. It was also in better condition than either Lochgreen or Darley, less beaten up.

The routing is not obvious, so keep the scorecard map handy, as the 8th and 9th sit amongst the back 9 holes. I went out in 38 gross for 20 points, then came home in 42 for 13. The 173-yard 12th earned a 6 and a blank. Final tally: 80 gross, 33 points.

The 11th, 199 yards: the longest of the six par 3s and a small target. The sky cleared just in time for the back nine.

Golf South Ayrshire sells Fullarton at £28 as a quick round for beginners, and should take less than three hours. The marketing copy is less reliable than the pricing, though. Its own GolfNow blurb promises eight par 3s; the scorecard has six. The GolfNow listing gives Fullarton a par of 71 and 6,785 yards, roughly Lochgreen’s length.

Who designed it, and when? Nobody seems to know. GolfNow says 1905. One app credits Joe Finger in 1983, a Texan who as far as I can tell never designed a hole in Scotland. Another says 1973, the year Troon Welbeck Golf Club was founded. Wikipedia hints that the course came with the Fullarton estate after the council bought it.

The 9th, a 133-yard par 3 with the edge of town behind the green. Fullarton was once the grounds of an estate; now the houses come right up to the course.

That estate has its own story. Fullarton House was built in 1745 and sold in the early 1800s to the Marquis of Titchfield, later the 4th Duke of Portland. The same family’s land gave Royal Troon its links across the railway. The council bought the house in 1928 and demolished it in 1966; the stables survive as Fullarton Courtyard. That is a story for another blog, and a reminder that the same Duke supplied the Open course and the town’s courses.

At £19.99 or the current GolfNow rate, Fullarton is good value at 4/5. At £28 list it is a fair 3.5/5. It is a short, quick, well-kept links, priced for exactly the golfers it is meant for.

Troon Links trilogy: Darley (Blog 136) for the money, Lochgreen (Blog 194) for the Open.

Facts:
Course Type: Inland links
Par: 66 (12 par 4s, 6 par 3s)
Distance: 4,724 yards (yellow)
Course Rating / Slope: 61.6 / 99
Course Quality: 3/5
Moly’s Gross Score: 80 (33 points)

Moly’s card, 80

187. Greenburn. 26 Mar 2023.

June 16, 2026 /

The Golf Club and the Viaduct – which will last longest?

Green Fee: £15 (winter rate). Par 71. Course Rating/Slope: 71/128 (yellow tees). Value: 4/5.

Moly’s Gross Score: 89

Playing Greenburn, I found myself thinking not just about where the course sits geographically – deep in Scotland’s central belt between Glasgow and Edinburgh – but where it sits economically. Scotland has around 575 golf courses and almost certainly cannot sustain all of them. I pondered which side of that financial reckoning Greenburn would end up on. Let’s park that for now.

Hole 4 – a long Par 5, with the first start view of the viaduct

Greenburn Golf Club traces its roots to 1894, when the working people of Fauldhouse built a course near their village. The present course, voluntarily built by the members in 1953, relocated to the Breichwater Valley. The club motto, Per Nostra Opera (“By our own endeavors”), says what it does on the tin.

I played at a winter rate of £15, off temporary mats but normal greens. I met recent retiree and local member Gordon Cleland, a decent golfer and clearly very much at home.

Local Member Gordon Cleland, local member, playing his approach at the par 5 13th.

After a welcoming opening hole, Greenburn becomes a narrow course, surrounded by industrial landmarks, most notably the electrified Glasgow to Edinburgh railway line. Pylons and overhead wires run over some holes.

The sometimes very large and sloping greens were in good condition for the end of winter. I got the feel they would be fast and very difficult in Summer.

The first, with characteristic large green, the rope marking the winter ground boundary

As you play toward the 4th green, a massive stone railway viaduct dominates – dark and monumental, it represents the ambition of the Victorian age, as does the existence of clubs like Greenburn. Nobody designs viaducts anymore, they’d be too expensive, but were they built to disturbingly outlast their surroundings.

Hole 3, one of the birdieable par 4 holes, with wide narrow green

The highlight of the course are a quartet of difficult par threes, a truism brought to life by Gordon’s tale of the Greenburn “secret 2s pot”. Most clubs have a small stake side comp along side the weekly medal, the “pot” shared by players getting a 2 on their card. At Greenburn this side sweep is on only one of the par 3s, but secretly chosen. Given the difficulty of the par 3s, the pot can accumulate. On one occasion, Gordon took home £340 for a birdie two at the 10th, the stroke index 5, ‘Muldron’ .

The 6th, at 171 yards, is the shortest of a quartet of great par threes at Greenburn

One disappointment was almost every bunker was marked GUR. Well-shaped, properly positioned, but out of play. Hopefully seasonal rather than structural.

Moly playing his ‘normal’ draw off the winter tee at the 14th, a tough par 4.

Greenburn is a good course, around mid-table in my ranking of Scotland’s courses that I’ve played. It sits in a central belt that offers a car-owning golfer several credible alternatives within thirty minutes. Membership at £738 a year is deliberately affordable — the club keeping itself within reach of its community. The £30 summer visitor is excellent value.

Shades of East Renfrewshire come to mind looking back from the 10th Green

So to the viaduct or course question.

The viaduct was built in an era when Fauldhouse had the population, the industry, and the collective will to anchor infrastructure for generations. The golf club was founded in the same spirit, by the same kind of people, in the same era. Both have lasted. But the economic conditions that created them, dense local population, limited mobility, a working community that played its local course because there was no other, have long since dissolved.

OOB down both sides of the fine 18th hole at Greenburn, likely ruin many a card.

Scotland probably cannot sustain 575 golf courses indefinitely. The adjustment will be slow and uneven, shaped by club type, geography, land ownership and sheer stubbornness. Members’ clubs built by communities like this one don’t close easily – they endure through loyalty, deferred maintenance, and people like Gordon who simply keep turning up. But the structural pressure is real, and it falls unevenly. A course in the middle of the quality distribution, in the middle of the country, with several competitors nearby and no obvious distinguishing draw for the visitor market, faces a particular kind of exposure that a municipal course or a well-capitalised commercial operation simply does not.

The viaduct will almost certainly outlast us all. The golf club? I genuinely hope it does too. But the question in the title isn’t rhetorical.

More on Scotland’s golfing landscape — and what the economics might mean for courses like this one — in a future post.

I scored 89. The course reminded me a little of East Ren (Blog 169).

Facts:

Course Type: Parkland/Moorland
Par: 71 (3 par 5s, 11 par 4s, 4 par 3s)
Distance: 5,659 yards (yellow tees)
Course Rating/Slope: 71/128 (yellow tees)
Moly’s Gross Score: 89
Green Fee: £15 (winter rate)
Value: 4/5

Moly’s 89, was a decent game.

186. Broadlees Par 3. 25 Mar 2023

June 14, 2026 /

Scotland’s first synthetic greens course, probably.

Price: £8. Par 27. Value: 4/5.

Moly’s Score: 31 (+4)

The backstory is in Blog 185, the main Broadlees course. In summary, since 2004, Robert and Barbara Anderson have built a diverse golf operation – range, 9-hole course, crazy golf, footgolf, academy, café and Santa’s grotto – to compete in an area stocked with golfing alternatives, many of them subsidised.

In 2021, they added something possibly unique in Scotland: a 9-hole par 3 course with synthetic greens and tees, playable every day of the year regardless of weather or ground conditions. The commercial reasoning is sound: a course needing no greenkeeping on its playing surfaces, generating income in January.

The first (97 yards) with the startlingly green synthetic surface immediately apparent against the March gloom. You are not playing a normal golf course.

From the start the scene is stripped back entirely with open ground, single windswept tree, and a synthetic “green” looking like a piece of discarded carpet. Not aesthetic, but very interesting, with the graves of golfing Architects stirring?

Synthetic tees matter commercially as much as the greens, as grass par 3 tees are brutally punished and need constant repair, reseeding, levelling and divot mix. The cost of upkeep of mats is negligible, plus they play consistently.

Hole 3 from elevated tee. The two wind turbines are a constant presence.

Holes range from 85 to 138 yards, so this is great wedge practice. They are not architecturally interesting in any way. But the holes have several water hazards to contend with.

The fourth green with synthetic pile; dense, uniform with its own playing logic.

The key question is “how do the greens play?”. The answer is situational. In wet March conditions the green surrounds were too soft for a chip and run approach. The only option was to fly the ball onto the front of the green and allow it to release. The surface bounces more than ‘checks’ on full shots, so that requires careful judgment. Land too deep into the green and the ball runs through; land short and it stops on wet grass short.

Short chips around the green, played softly, were a different matter — the synthetic pile had enough give to generate some check, certainly more than expected. A useful discovery, though it came too late on the card to rescue early bogeys. On the greens themselves the ball rolled true, although breaking differently from a grass surface.

The 9th (91 yards), looking towards the Broadlees clubhouse, with cafe, range, and main course off to the right.

I shot 31 gross, four over par. On the two holes where I holed from outside ten feet I correctly read that the ball would not break as much as expected. It was an education. I’m sure regular players hole lots of putts.

At £8 for nine holes (2023) this is great ‘novelty’ value. I would think there is a commercial opportunity to price a combined fee with 9 holes on this course and 9 holes on the main Broadlees course.

Value: 4/5, to play Scotland’s first and possibly only synthetic greens course

Facts:

Course type: Par 3, synthetic tees and greens

Par 27 . Distance: 972 yards.

Moly’s Gross Score: 31 (+4)

See also: Blog 185 — Broadlees Golf Course

« Older posts

© 2026 Scotland Golf Bible

Theme by Anders Noren — Up ↑