Scotland Golf Bible

A guide to green fee value for money

Category: James Braid (Page 1 of 12)

197. Seafield. 2 May 23.

October 27, 2026 /

Belleisle’s little sister. Born on a racecourse, raised in the shadow of a more renowned sibling.

Price Paid: £19.99 (GolfNow)
Current Price (2026): £32 list; £32 GolfNow, with hot deals from £21
Value: 4/5 at £19.99 / 3/5 at £32 / 4/5 at £21
Moly’s Score: 85 gross, nett 73, 31 Stableford points (off 12)

Fran with her approach on the 17th. This is not typical of what Seafield looks like, most is flat and easy walking.

My final South Ayrshire council course, and the smaller of the two within Belleisle Park. Seafield shares its estate, pro shop and car park with Belleisle (Blog 189), and GolfNow calls it “Belleisle’s Little Sister.” That’s fair, but the family history is more interesting than the nickname.

Long before golf, there were horses. Ayr races were run at Seafield from 1771 on an oval with bends likely to unseat a jockey. Its patrons included the Earl of Eglinton, the Duke of Portland and the Caledonian Hunt, to whom Burns dedicated his Edinburgh edition in 1787. The Ayr Gold Cup, one of the UK’s richest sprint handicaps, was raced here. In 1907 the track was judged too small for racing which moved to Craigie. Part of the old oval became part of Seafield golf course.

The 1st, from the elevated tee down into the burn valley. It’s a fine opening view, and one of only a handful of holes with any real change in height.

When golf started here is less clear. A 1988 greenkeeping article says nine holes were laid out inside the racecourse in 1904, which would have meant golfers dodging racehorses for three years. GolfNow says 1907, then “redesigned by James Braid in 1927.” A long-standing course list says 1930. Braid certainly designed Belleisle in 1927. For Seafield, I couldn’t find an independent source that names him, and the 1988 article calls it the “poor relation.” I suspect the Braid credit came across from big sister along with the shared car park. Until someone shows me a plan with his name on it, it’s unproven.

Behind the 12th green: View House, once the racecourse grandstand. Today it’s boarded-up arches and a toilet block.

The racing connection still stands. View House, built in 1867 by the Ayr architect James McDerment, provided changing rooms and viewing terraces for the Western Meeting and by 1957 was a golf clubhouse. It isn’t anyone’s clubhouse now. Belleisle got the smart new building. Seafield got the leftovers of the racecourse.

Moly lining up a putt on the 13th beneath ivy-clad Scots pines and the old estate wall. The greens were in good order, with the wall in play on a few holes.

The golf is pleasant. At 5,452 yards off the whites, par 68 with no par 5s, it’s short but not trivial. Fourteen par 4s give it a steady rhythm, and the four par 3s ask enough questions. It sits in a more salubrious part of Ayr than Dalmilling (Blog 192), and it feels like it. The turf and greens were good, and most of the course is flat parkland. The burn valley only comes into play on the 1st and 16th, which are the holes people photograph. I went out in 40 and came home in 45 for 31 points, respectable rather than memorable.

Moly driving off the 16th across the burn and footbridge, with the fairway climbing to the bunkers. This is Seafield at its most dramatic, so enjoy it while it lasts.

Two gripes. There were too few rakes for the number of bunkers. And the café was shut by 3.30pm on a spring afternoon. South Ayrshire markets this place to the world as part of its golf coast. I’m not sure what an American visitor makes of finishing 18 holes in Burns country and finding nowhere to buy a cup of tea.

The 14th, a very typical hole at Seafield

At £19.99 on GolfNow, Seafield is a well-kept, enjoyable 18 holes for less than a round of drinks in the clubhouse it doesn’t have. That’s 4/5. At £32 list you’re paying a full municipal fee for the lesser course, with Belleisle next door. That’s 3/5. The £21 hot deals bring it back to 4/5. It’s a minor course, honestly priced when discounted, and its history is more interesting than its golf.

Facts:
Course Type: Parkland
Par: 68 (0 par 5s, 14 par 4s, 4 par 3s)
Distance: 5,452 yards (whites)
Course Rating / Slope: 66.5 / 111
Course Quality: 3/5
Moly’s Gross Score: 85

Steady round of 85, with all 4s, 5s or 6s.

196. Girvan.1 May 23.

October 25, 2026 /

Is this where the Girvan Gang played?

Price Paid – £15 (GolfNow)
Current Price – £24 list (2026); £17 GolfNow
Value – 4/5 at £15 / [GolfNow tbc] / 3.5/5 at £24
Moly’s Score – 81 gross (31 Stableford points)

Moly off the 5th tee, aiming straight at Ailsa Craig. 171 yards of links, and the wind decides the club.

In my Turnberry Ailsa blog (Blog 188) I introduced the Girvan Gang. In a letter of 1751 they appear as a gaggle of lairds, a minister and a doctor playing golf at Girvan, with Sir John adjudicating both the golf and the drinking. That was three years before the St Andrews golfers formed their Society. So where did they play?

Nobody wrote it down. In a town of about a thousand souls there were only two candidates: the town green, now Stair Park and rows of Victorian villas, or the shore north of the river, where holes one to eight run today. My money is on the shore. If I’m right, Girvan’s first eight holes may be the oldest golfing ground still in play in Ayrshire.

Moly on the 1st tee, off the whites. Firth on the left, Arran on the horizon, and the old shore turf ahead.

The documented story is just as good. In 1892 Girvan’s golfers held an open-air meeting on the ruins of Turnberry Castle and formed a club to play the Turnberry links. Nine years later, when their nine-hole course north of the river was sold for villas, they moved there. Turnberry, in effect, was founded by Girvan. But Turnberry was five miles away and too far for winter golf. So in 1903 the town leased 40 acres of shore, and David Kinnell of Prestwick St Nicholas laid out nine holes on it. He thought them the finest of their size. Directories still credit James Braid. I can find no evidence he did anything here.

Fran off the 2nd, Arran across the water.

The Course

The eight links holes are a delight: firm, rumpled and wind-blown, with a run of brutal par 3s. From the whites, the 3rd is 220 yards, the 7th is 215 and the 8th is 243. It’s the kind of small, magical links that could stand beside Shiskine on Arran, the sort you’d travel just to play.

Ailsa Craig wearing its cloud cap behind the 5th green. Golf has been played on this shore since at least 1891, a decade before Turnberry existed.

Then you cross the road. In 1911 the members, wanting to “remove the congestion”, took a field along the river and extended to 18 holes. The council took the course over in the 1920s and bought it outright in 1926 for £3,000. So the council didn’t make the parkland, but it has had a century to put things right and hasn’t. Of those ten inland holes, two are good, maybe three if you’re generous to the 18th. The rest are flat field golf with a river attached, and the backdrop changes from Ailsa Craig to William Grant’s grain distillery, the Girvan end of the family that gives the world Glenfiddich and, from these very stills, Hendrick’s gin.

Looking back from the 8th tee along the old raised beach. In 1903 the papers praised the “range of hills” sheltering the course. The town Kinnell’s golfers walked from sits at the far end.
The 16th green, under the gaze of Hendrick’s gin. From Ailsa Craig to the distillery in eight holes.

In fairness, the bunkering is excellent throughout, and the island bunker at the 12th is genuinely handsome.

Something worth photographing on the inland half: the island bunker at the 12th.

The Oddities

The clubhouse sits on the road between the two halves, the starter’s hut sits somewhere else, and the starter was the grumpiest I’ve met in a while. On a municipal course, the person at the hut is the welcome. Get that wrong and nothing else recovers it.

The tee colours run white, red, yellow, with yellow as the shortest set for everyone. The stroke indices differ between tees: the 15th is SI 1 off white and SI 7 off red. Fran spotted the yellows were the forward tees and played them, so she got the shortest yardage but ladies’ par 65, with the long par 3s staying par 3s.

Girvan’s handicap board: white, red, yellow, in that order. Visitors, take note.

The Missed Opportunity

The practice green beside the starter’s box looks very much like an old 9th. Behind it, nearer the town, there’s a strip of land that could make Girvan a proper nine-hole links. How many Scottish towns have swapped a brilliant nine for a mediocre 18? Girvan is the clearest case I’ve seen. The council could give the town its links back, the ground where the Girvan Gang may have played, untouched and uncrafted. It hasn’t.

The Verdict

At £15 on GolfNow, 4/5: the front eight alone are worth it. At £24, 3.5/5. Would I go back? For the front eight, gladly.

Facts:
Course Type: Links (holes 1–8) / Parkland (9–18)
Par: 64 (no par 5s, 10 par 4s, 8 par 3s)
Distance: 5,086 yards (white)
Course Rating / Slope: 64.5 / 105
Course Quality: 3/5
Moly’s Gross Score: 81 (net 69, 31 Stableford)

Moly’s scorecard, gross 81

194. Troon Links (Lochgreen). 29 Apr 23.

October 24, 2026 /

The road to the Open ran through this municipal course for forty years; Jack Nicklaus took it, though not the way the legend tells it.

Price Paid: £19.99 (GolfNow)
Current Price (2026): £38 list; £30 GolfNow Hot Deal
Value (out of 5): 5 at price paid / 5 at current GolfNow / 4.5 at current list
Moly’s Score: 85 gross, 72 nett, 38 Stableford points (playing handicap 13)

The 5th, stroke index 1, runs beside the Glasgow to Ayr railway. On the far side of the line lie Royal Troon’s members’ courses. On this side, the people’s golf. Moly took a 7.

In my Troon Darley blog (136) I wrote about two tiers of Scottish golf: Royal Troon’s clubhouse and the Troon Links clubhouse are less than a mile, but a world, apart. Lochgreen is where those two worlds used to meet.

From 1923 to 1962, anyone who wanted to play in The Open at Troon first had to qualify, and half the qualifying was on the municipal course. In 1923 it was still called Troon Municipal No.2. Gene Sarazen shot 75 on it on the Monday. On the Tuesday he went out first on Troon’s New (Portland) course into the worst of the rain and wind, shot 85, and failed to qualify. Walter Hagen scraped in on 159. The municipal half had not been Sarazen’s hurdle.

The 15th tee, framed by pines and full flowering broom, a highlight all round the course.

The 1962 Open was the last with no qualifying exemptions, so even the reigning US Open champion, a 22-year-old Jack Nicklaus, had to play a round over Royal Troon’s Old Course and one over Lochgreen. Every Lochgreen write-up mentions this. One goes further, claiming he “shot an 82 and then a 68 on the Troon Links Lochgreen course to qualify by one shot”.

Fran on the 12th tee, in the “Dovecot Section”. Three holes of mature estate parkland, a different course entirely from the links holes either side.

It doesn’t add up. Only one of the two qualifying rounds was on Lochgreen. The qualifying mark was 154, and 82 plus 68 is 150, four shots inside it. The figures look borrowed from the championship proper. Nicklaus opened with 80 on the Old Course, including a 10 at the 11th, then shot 72, making 152, exactly the halfway cut. Twelve players on 153 went home. So the scramble happened, but on Royal Troon, not here. Somewhere along the way the legend crossed the railway line. His actual qualifying scores have so far eluded me.

The 16th, a par 5 with devilish bunkers cut into a heathery bank, unseen from the fairway until you’re on top of them. The bunkering is Lochgreen’s strongest feature.

So, the course? Lochgreen is quite long. At par 74 with five par 5s, it’s the longest of the three Troon Links courses. The par flatters, though. From the yellows the Course Rating is 71.1, nearly three shots below par. Under the handicap rules in force in 2023, that worked in my favour: the 38 points came against a par the rating says is soft. Since April 2024, Scotland’s handicap formula deducts the difference, and the same round off the same index would give a course handicap of 10, not 13, and around 35 points. Lochgreen’s par 74 used to be a three-shot present to every Stableford player who teed it up there.

The 6th green, a tough par 3. A deep revetted bunker, properly shaped and properly punishing: the quality of Lochgreen in a single frame.

The links holes play over firm turf that I suspect differs little from Royal Troon’s across the line. The driving is generous, but the greenside bunkering is not: deep, revetted and properly placed. The 5th, with the railway tight on the right, is the hole to remember, and it was my only blank on the card. Holes 11 to 13 break off into the parkland of the Dovecot Section, with veteran trees, a stone ruin and a reed bed behind one green. That suits a course named after a loch drained long ago. The Lochgreen name survives; the loch itself is now a culverted burn.

The approach to the 13th: crisp greenside bunkers in the parkland stretch, with a reed bed behind, the nearest thing left to a loch at Lochgreen.

The condition was the weak point. A year after my Darley round, and a month later in the season, the fairways were still thin, worn and straw-coloured. Nothing about the Glasgow winter overflow I described in Blog 136 had changed. The greens held up; I just didn’t hole anything on them. Better putting would have made it a very good round rather than a decent one.

The 10th green, a par 3 in good order. It was getting to it that showed the wear.

On value, one development since Blog 136. Then, GolfNow was the competitor the council was responding to with “dynamic pricing”. Now South Ayrshire sells its tee times through GolfNow’s own platform. The discount app has become the shop counter. At £19.99, Lochgreen was 5/5. At the current £30 Hot Deal it still is. At £38 list it drops half a point, mostly because of the condition. It’s still a long, historic, properly bunkered links for a fraction of the price across the line, if you could get on, that is!

Fran putting on the 18th green in front of the Troon Links clubhouse, the shared home of Lochgreen, Darley and Fullarton.

Next, Fullarton (Blog 195), the shortest course of the three, where the land story begins.

Facts:

Course Type: Links, with a three-hole parkland stretch
Par: 74 (5 par 5s, 10 par 4s, 3 par 3s)
Distance: 6,476 yards (yellow)
Course Rating / Slope: 71.1 / 120 (yellow)
Course Quality: 3.5/5
Moly’s Gross Score: 85 (38 points)

Moly’s Lochgreen scorecard: 85 gross, 38 points. The 7 at the 5th was the only blank.


190. Irvine ‘Bogside’. 26 Apr 23.

August 28, 2026 /

An Example of the Golf Market Leaving Normal Golfers Behind

Price Paid: £32 (via GolfNow)
Current Price (2026): £125 (summer, May-Sep)
Value: 5/5 at price paid. 2/5 at current list price.

Tucked between the Ayrshire coastal railway line and the mouth of the River Irvine, this course is shadowed by more famous neighbours, giving an occasional opportunity for value.

Fran facing the magnificent sleeper bunker at the 5th, “Sandface”.

In 1887 Eglinton Estates leased land for a course to be built between the railway, the river, the village of Bartonholm and the ‘Bogside’ racecourse. The racecourse had opened in 1808 and from 1867 hosted the Scottish Grand National, but money ran out and the last meeting ran in 1965, with the Grand National moving south to Ayr. The 11th hole is called “Grandstand” although no remnants exist.

Approach to the 11th “Grandstand”; nothing remains of the racecourse grandstand.

The golf course is strategic fare. Willie Fernie, professional at Troon, made the first significant alterations after the original 1887 layout, and Harold Hilton surveyed the course in 1912. But much of what’s here now is Braid’s,including four entirely new holes (the 10th, 11th, 12th and 13th) carved from land bought from the neighbouring farms and the Eglinton estate.

When we played, the turf was superb given how early in the year, with fast, subtle greens. Not every hole is tight, the 7th, The Cup, is as wide open as Bogside gets, a breather after the squeeze of the holes before it.

Moly at the short par 4 7th, the wide fairway narrows significantly around 230 yards.

The course has some very difficult holes, no more so than ‘Cannon Hill’, the 6th, a worthy stroke index 1.

The approach to the difficult par four 6th, “Cannon Hill’s”, the stroke index 1 hole.

The railway is often in play and gives the course added edge, out of bounds running the length of several holes. The 4th, The Moor, is the hole people talk about: a pond hard against the tee, out of bounds down the left, and a green backed directly onto the railway boundary, the line’s overhead gantries filling the skyline behind the flag.

Tron Carter (TC) of No Laying Up loves the 4th at Bogside.


It’s not just me rating it; Tron Carter of the No Laying Up podcast built himself a fantasy 18-hole course on episode 1151, one hole per course he’d played, matched by hole number, and Bogside’s 4th made the cut as part of his dream.

Here’s my one real gripe. There’s a fair amount of blind driving and approach work through the round, notably at the 12th, one of Braid’s own new holes, no less and again at the 14th, where the green sits in its own hidden punchbowl. That sits oddly against the man who redesigned the course: Braid wrote in Advanced Golf (1908) that blind holes should be avoided, “and especially a blind shot to the green.”

The ‘blind’ 14th green, where the bowl should help your approach find the green.

Now the value case. I paid £32 through GolfNow; today’s rack rate is £90–£125 depending on season, and GolfNow itself is currently listing Bogside at £115 with no Hot Deals running, barely a discount off list price. There’s a folk explanation clubs like to reach for here, that American visitors equate a high green fee with quality, so pricing low would actually cost business. It doesn’t hold up well under scrutiny. A lot of US visitors book through tour operators, buying flights, hotels and golf as a single package, and never see the individual green fee at all; they can’t be pricing courses on a fee they don’t see. What overseas visitors genuinely lack is a reference point: what a comparable course nearby charges, or what this course cost a few years ago. That’s a much simpler explanation for why fees have room to rise unnoticed than any theory about American taste. Whatever the reasoning, Irvine’s tripled its rate since 2023, and the golfer picking up the difference isn’t the tourist it’s golfer like me, deciding whether this round is still worth it. At £32, this was one of the best value rounds I’ve played anywhere in Scotland; Open Final Qualifying pedigree, Braid’s bunkering, a genuinely varied test, for municipal money. At today’s prices — list or GolfNow, that value case collapses; this is a 2/5 course at what it costs now.

The 18th tee and, right on cue, a reminder of the neighbours. .

It finished well, at least. The 18th runs you out almost to the clubhouse door, and it was worth lingering afterwards in the lovely old building with real history inside; Old Tom Morris attended a professional tournament here in 1919, and his signed photograph still hangs on the wall.

A wedge into the 18th, Flagstaff, found enough of the green to leave a putt worth having, and it dropped for a birdie three — the kind of ending that forgives a round its rough patches.

Facts: Course Type — Links/Heathland. Par 71 (yellow tees). Distance — 6,152 yards (Yellow tees).

Moly’s Gross Score, 93 (nett 79).

Moly’s Irvine ‘Bogside’ scorecard
« Older posts

© 2026 Scotland Golf Bible

Theme by Anders Noren — Up ↑