A guide to green fee value for money

Category: Dundee & Angus (Page 3 of 6)

59. Edzell. 15th Dec 2016.

Great course worth playing, but only good value with discounted green fee

Round £60.  Par 71.  Value (out of 5) 3.

Edzell Golf Course, in the nice village of Edzell close to the Angus Glens, was established in 1895.  It is located close to the main A90 between Dundee and Aberdeen so is very easily accessed and well worth playing.

The course was designed by Bob Simpson, with further input from James Braid in the 1930s and recently in 2015 was upgraded by Martin Ebert of Mackenzie & Ebert a company with a growing and prestigious global catalogue.  The current course lays testimony to golfing architecture at its best; the course fits naturally to its surroundings with, in particular, a great array of fairway bunkers which will especially challenge the longer hitters.

The dangerous 9th hole approach – keep it left!

The course is part heathland part parkland but the fairways are generous.  The greens are very large, with some subtle fairway hollows, making it important to check your yardage.  Some of the front flag locations are very tricky when coupled to the tight greenside bunkering.

The par 3 14th at Edzell emblazed with Winter sun

After a relatively straight forward par 4 first, the 2nd, 4th and 5th are all long par 4s, at well over 400 yards.   The 6th is also a tricky par 3 with 5 green side bunkers, where most golfers will be using a hybrid or fairway wood.  After a bit of respite at 7 and 8, the par 5 9th presents a hazardous approach with a steep river bank close to the right of the green. Play well left with your second and third shots, in my advice.

The 15th, with a typical array of dangerous fairway bunkers

To score well at Edzell you need to get through the first 9 without disaster (I didn’t!). I suspect many cards are deposited in a waste bin before the 10th tee!

Of the many highlights on the back 9, my favourite was the aptly named 16th, the “Spion Kop”, with 2 very large green side bunkers on a devilishly sloping bank.  Don’t take on a front pin here.

The relatively straight forward par 5 18th, with the fine clubhouse and Edzell village in the background

The course was playing winter tees but full greens when I played and in excellent condition, although several of the bunkers were undergoing re-construction; this didn’t dilute my enjoyment though.   I played pretty well for a 97, or 29 stableford points, including the front 9 disasters.

My only gripe is I think the headline green fee, at £60 in summer, is slightly high, no doubt subsidising the £550 membership fees.  However, I played using teeofftimes and got a good deal.

Some Facts

Course Type: Parkland/heathland

Par 71 (2 par 5, 13 par 4s, 3 par 3s)

Distance yards:  6182

Moly’s Gross Score: 97

Moly’s Edzell Scorecard – played better than the score of 97 suggests, for 29 points (16 hcp)

49. Montrose Broomfield. 2nd Sep 2016.

This flat and featureless links is a poor Montrose companion

Round £25.  Par 66.  Value (out of 5) 2

Golf was first recorded on the Montrose Links in 1562 which makes it the fifth oldest links in the world; only at St Andrews has golf been played continuously longer on the same land.

First at Montrose Broomfield - a typical hole on this flat course.

First at Montrose Broomfield – a typical hole on this flat course.

Montrose is therefore heaped in golfing history, but whilst the Medal course can lay claim to historical greatness, one should not get over enthused by its smaller neighbour – the Broomfield course.  It was originally a 9 hole course laid out in 1907, and then extended to 18 by the renowned architect Harry Colt, during a time when he was significantly altering the Medal course, one of his earlier golfing works.

The 9th green on The Broomfield close to the Montrose town.

The 9th green on The Broomfield close to the Montrose town.

The Broomfield is a short and pretty flat links course, which will vary in difficultly wholly dependent on the wind.  At only 4822 yards from the common white/red tees, this is a course that is within reach of most golfers, and there are several birdie opportunities, evidenced by my score of 79, the first time for several years I have broken 80, including birdies at the par 4 1st and 15th holes.  I was playing off my new handicap of 17:)

The secret of good scoring was keeping the ball on the fairway, and avoiding the relatively few, but deep, bunkers, plus avoiding the small burn that came into play on the 3rd, 4th and 13th fairways and in front of the 5th and 12th greens.

The 11th on The Broomfield, one of the few more defined holes.

The 11th on The Broomfield, one of the few more defined holes.

When I played the greens were in good condition, but the tees were in need of more care – the fairways were typically dried out allowing significant roll, meaning approach shots had to be judged carefully.

Par 3 17th at The Broomfield in Montrose

Par 3 17th at The Broomfield in Montrose

The highlights for me were the holes played towards the town, namely the 9th and 15th, which give a real sense of the historical closeness between the people and golf.  There were also a couple of holes, the 8th and 11th, which being more enclosed by surrounding shrubs, making them more memorable.

In summary, Broomfield is a good course to learn the game, or for a warm up before playing the Medal, but not worth going out of your way to play on its own.

Some Facts

Course Type: Links

Par 66 (12 par 4s, 6 par 3s)

Distance Yards   4822 (white) 

Moly’s Gross Score: 79

Moly's rare Broomfield scorecard - a 79!

Moly’s rare Broomfield scorecard – a 79!

41. Letham Grange Glens. 3rd Jun 2016. CLOSED

Mainly open parkland course, with a tough finishing stretch

Round  £30 ( variable on-line).   Par 68.  Value (out of 5) – 2.5

Letham Grange, on the outskirts of Arbroath, has likely had more written about it in court proceedings than in golfing magazines! It is one of the failed attempts in Scotland to create an American style Golf & Country Club Estate similar to Gleneagles, or Wentworth in Surrey.  Opened in 1987 as a full resort, the hotel and many facilities are long since closed.

Approach to the 2nd on the Glens at Letham Grange, a typical open parkland hole.

Approach to the 2nd on the Glens at Letham Grange, a typical open parkland hole.

The club members, several living in the many fine houses which still adorn the fairways, now do a great job at keeping the Old course and the smaller Glens course open.

The Glens Course opened in 1992 and is at 5528 yards, much shorter and less demanding than the Old course. The parkland layout is very open for the first 12 holes, but the stretch from the 13th to 17th is much more challenging and will dictate your scorecard.

The 9th green at Letham Grange Glens course

The 9th green at Letham Grange Glens course

In particular the short par 4 14th requires a very acurate tee shot; the dog leg 15th needs a straight shot of about 200 yards to the tree lined dog-leg; and the 17th is a pretty scary drive down an avenue of trees about 40 yards wide.

The condition of the course was pretty reasonable, with the highlight being the very well maintained teeing grounds.  However, the bunkers though were actually terrible, with a thin covering of grainy sand over hard packed earth – unfortunately I found several bunkers eventually realising the only way to play them was to chip the ball cleanly off the sand.

The difficult to find small 15th green, part of the difficult stretch of 5 holes from 13 to 17 on the Glens course

The difficult to find small 15th green, part of the difficult stretch of 5 holes from 13 to 17 on the Glens course

The price of the Glens is £30 per round and I was able to play on the Carnoustie Country offer, and paid only £15.  At the full price its not the best value by any means in Angus.

I had a good round with 37 stableford points (using the new 9/10s allowance), and played to my new handicap of 18, which included an 8 on the par 4 3rd, needing to take 2 shots to get out of a greenside bunker.

Some Facts

Course Type: Parkland

Par 68 (2 par 5s, 10 par 4s, 6 par 3s)

Distance (white)   5528 yards

Moly’s Gross Score  86

Moly's Letham Grange Glens Scorecard - 86 (net par off 18)

Moly’s Letham Grange Glens Scorecard – 86 (net par off 18)

28. Brechin. 22nd Aug 2015

Weak link in the Braid Association?

Round  £40 (variable).   Par 72.  Value (out of 5) – 2.5

Green at the par 3 third at Brechin

Green at the par 3 third at Brechin

This 6162 yard, 18 hole parkland course, was founded in 1893 and is part of the Braid Association – a group of courses designed by James Braid, which gives golf playing discounts to members of courses within the association.    On closer examination, some of the association’s courses have fairly tenuous links to Braid – in Brechin’s case, it’s website claims:

“By 1926 the famous James Braid was invited to play the course.  J.P Gellatly, the Club’s Captain at the time, generously offered to pay his fee.  Braid was so impressed he suggested suitable sites for sand bunkers in the Limefield section (holes 10-17) of the course.”

The tricky and fun par 4 8th at Brechin

The tricky and fun par 4 8th at Brechin

It’s clear that holes 10-17 are the best part of the course, with holes 13 and 14 being the toughest in my book – the greens are also measurably better in the section and some of the best in the area.  However stand on the first tee and you’ll realise this is a weak addition to the Braid association.

12th green at Brechin with views of the Angus Hills

12th green at Brechin with views of the Angus Hills

Moreover, several of the holes are new editions in the 1990s, and fairly bland additions at that.  These new holes are on either side of the Brechin A90 bypass and designed by John Farrell.

The 8th deserves a mention, which is a shortish par 4, with a very small gap in a line of trees – the only tactic I could see was take driver and try and clear the trees – there is an ironically placed wishing well to the front right of the green – I enjoyed this humour from the Members:)

Brechin is nevertheless in a nice setting, with good views of the Angus Glens, and is easily accessible and close to the main Dundee-Aberdeen road – coupled with some good clubhouse facilities it would make an excellent venue for a society golf day.  However, the amount of road noise is significant.

Brechin's 17th green

Brechin’s 17th green

It’s a well kept course, with nice fairways and greens, but the £40 per round is a bit over priced in my opinion, hence the value for money score of 2.5.

I played well on the front 9, but 3 “blobs” on the back meant I ended up with a 97, for 31 stableford points.

Some Facts

Course Type: Parkland

Par 72 (4 par 5s, 10 par 4s, 4 par 3s)

Distance (white)   6162 yards

Moly’s Gross Score  97

Moly's Brechin Scorecard - 97

Moly’s Brechin Scorecard – 97

« Older posts Newer posts »

© 2024 Scotland Golf Bible

Theme by Anders NorenUp ↑