Category: Aberdeen City and Shire (Page 2 of 3)

80. Torphins. 25 June 2018.

August 5, 2018 / Moly McMillan

Incredible value at this gem of a 9 hole course

Round £10. Par 32. Value (out of 5) – 5

Torphins Golf Club is situated in Royal Deeside, in the village of the same name, 23 miles west of Aberdeen and 7 miles north-west of Banchory. This 9 hole golf course was founded in 1891 and the club established in 1896. I couldn’t find any record of the course designer or the course’s history, which is a real pity, as this really is a “Hidden Gem”, that oft-used but, so often, disappointingly flattering term.

My drive at the 9th at Torphins heading to the left of the fairway (but in play)

Torphins is an undulating parkland course with far reaching views of the countryside and it is worth going out of your way to play. It actually has 10 greens, with the 3rd and 12th holes sharing the same teeing ground and fairway, but the 2 greens are separated by a copse of trees.

The lovely 3rd and 12th fairway from the common teeing ground at Torphins.

It is a great little golf course, with plenty of variation, and some really tricky holes. There are 4 blind tee shots, one being the par 4 6th (SI 1), a tough dog leg left hole, which I should have taken driver from the tee, as the apex to the dog leg is further than in looks as it is quite uphill.

The greens were pretty small but in really excellent condition as were the fairways and tees.

Fran chipping at the short par 3 5th at Torphins. A bit of respite before the challenging 6th hole

Value: whether as a member or as a visitor, Torphins represents incredible golfing value. The 9 hole quoted rate was only £10, but my wife Fran and I payed only £7.50 each through the club website. A Monday to Friday annual membership, allowing 9 holes per day, is only £90, with Junior memberships starting at £20. This is 5 star value golf.

The 2nd, a short par 4, at Torphins – my birdie hole on the day.

An interesting fact – Macbeth was killed on 15 August 1057 only 3 miles from Torpins. “What’s done cannot be undone”, sayeth Macbeth – that’s how I felt on the 7th after my 10, having lost 2 balls! I still shot 17 point for the 9 holes.

Really enjoyable, highly recommended.

Facts:

Course Type: Parkland

Par 32 (white; 5 par 4s, 4 par 3s)

Distance: 2338 yards

Moly’s Gross score: 44

Torphins scorecard – 44 for 17 points (with a 7 and 10!)

76. Meldrum House. 19 June 2018.

July 8, 2018 / Moly McMillan

Aberdeenshire’s “exclusive golf experience” is untypically Scottish and fails to deliver value

Round £85 + hotel residency. Par 70. Value (out of 5) – 2

Let’s get something clear – Meldrum House is a beautifully crafted parkland golf course cut among the agricultural heartland of Aberdeenshire. The quality and design, by Graham Webster, is of a very high standard. However (yes, there is a big one), in establishing the course as “the exclusive golf experience”, Meldrum House feels so untypically Scottish. It felt much more like playing, for example, the AA Golf Club in Epsom, than a Scottish golf course.

Perhaps that’s why there was a need to stock some Highland Cattle between the 17th fairway and the manufactured lawns of the Country House hotel of the same name, otherwise one might think you were playing the very many lookalike late 1900s courses developed in the southern counties of Surrey or Hampshire.

The rare Highland Cattle compliment the surroundings at Meldrum House – 17th hole behind.

The only way to play a single round is to stay at the 4-star Meldrum House hotel, which allows guests to play the course for a fee of £85. Therefore, with dinner, bed and breakfast, a round here is going to cost at least £250+. Hence why I’ve assessed its value rating as 2.

Meldrum House hotel provides great accommodation and the estate of the same name has a long heralded history, with the Barony of Meldrum dating back to the 13th Century. So, if you were looking for an Aberdeenshire short break with a bit of golf and good food, it’s a great option.

For the record, individual membership (2018 prices) of Meldrum House golf club is £1,895, although for that the club does consider it “our privilege to have our members”. Unsurprisingly, business memberships are available, and start at over £5,000. Of course, there lies the likely clue to the golf course’s existence, which seems to rest on the wealthy oil industry of the North East. I’ll wager that this course will not be around in it’s current format, once the North Sea oil is long gone. Why pay these Meldrum House fees when membership of one of the world’s best courses, Cruden Bay, is £680, and only about 22 miles away?

Par 3 10th hole, one of the 7 water feature holes in the first 10 at Meldrum House.

The course has a headline length of over 7000 yards from the black tees, but I suspect most will play from the White (6203) or Yellow (5867) tees, the latter which I used while playing with my wife Fran who used the Red (5492).

There is water genuinely in play at 11 of the 18 holes, and at 7 of the first 10. There is also many very deep bunkers. To score well, you need to play strategically around here and pay close attention to the course planner (included in the fee!). I did this pretty well other than at the 8th, the aptly named “The Lochans”, and the 18th (more of later); the 8th fairway slopes left to right towards the water hazard, which I surprisingly found after a well struck drive; the smart play is a hybrid from the tee to the left side of the fairway.

The beautiful 16th hole at Meldrum House, characteristic of the course.

Holes 11 through 15 play on the higher part of the course, with no water hazards, but the stretch starts with what can be described as a “gimmicky” 11th hole which has a disaster of 15 (yes 15) bunkers in front of the green approach. I couldn’t help wondering what the record is for the most, separate, bunkers ever played from on a single hole??

The “gimmicky” long par 5 11th, with bunkers covering 70 yards of the green approach.

The course was in very good condition when I played other than one fairway (9th) which was poor. The greens were beautiful, the tees and bunkers well kept and manicured. It was also a very pleasant walk and, of course, there was hardly any other players!

The 18th, unusually, was a short to medium iron, par 3, played over 2 sets of marshy water hazards. Unfortunately, I found both hazards for a 7, my second quadruple bogie of the day, along with the 9th, which ruined an otherwise impressive card. I still shot 90 for 35 points.

13th green, site of my only birdie of the day at Meldrum House

Oh, I nearly forgot to mention – coffee & tee were “free” in the clubhouse;)

Facts:

Course Type: Parkland

Par 70 (3 par 5s, 10 par 4s, 5 par 3s)

Distance (yellow): 5867

Moly’s Gross score: 90

Moly’s Meldrum House Scorecard – 90 for 35 points

61. Ballater. 2nd Aug 2017.

August 3, 2017 / Moly McMillan

Good course in the heart of Deeside which offers challenge for all levels.

Summary: Cost £35. Par 67. Score 94. Value (out of 5) – 3.

Ballater seemed a good choice to return to golf blogging after several months absence due mainly to my sojourn to watch the British Lions take on the All Blacks. Ballater is 40 miles east of Aberdeen, in the heart of Royal Deeside, an area I spent many happy years hill walking in during my teens. The “royal” tag comes as Balmoral Castle, The Queen’s summer residence, is only a few miles away.

18th green and large clubhouse at Ballater

A nine hole golf course was founded in Ballater in 1892, and extended to 18 in 1905, the pedigree of the course demonstrated by an exhibition match between James Braid and Harry Vardon in 1906.

Although the course is described on it’s web site as mainly heathland with parkland characteristics, I beg to differ and say it’s actually the other way round, and felt much more parkland to me. Although surrounded by hills and forest, the course is surprisingly flat and offers an easy walk. With many fairways adjacent to each other, with only light rough in between, it offers regular opportunity to be wild off the tee and still easily find your ball – something I unfortunately took advantage of often! However, overall this is not an easy course with some very tricky greenside bunkers (some of which are blind to your approach shots) and some very penal rough.

The very large 1st green at Ballater

Although the course lies close to the River Dee the river does not come into play as often, by comparison, as Braemar (further along the Dee). These open fairways and lack of water in play, means the course is quite good for holiday golfers. However, the course is quite busy and I would recommend booking, especially during the Summer months.

The course has some challenges in particular the opening six holes are very tough – I double bogied the first 5 holes, and actually felt I struck the ball well! The 3 par 3s on the opening 9 holes are particularly tough, culminating with the 9th hole which has a semi blind small green.

The typically Scottish 2nd green at Ballater with the town houses in background

The course was in all round good condition when I played, with good greens and lush but firm fairways. I played better than my scorecard would suggest. It felt like a 30 point day, but with 3 balls lost, for 6 penalties, made it only 25 points. I had a nice birdie 2 on the par 3 17th though.

I played having booked through the teeofftimes.co.uk website and paid £22.50 versus the course published price of £35 for a midweek round. At £22.50 it would be worth 4/5 for value but only 3/5 using its rack rate.

It’s worth playing this nice course, which also has a big bar and good value restaurant food.

Tricky Par 3 5th at Ballater

Note: I had to use my phone for pictures, which are not the usual standard….sorry!

Key Facts

Course Type: Parkland

Par 67 (0 par 5s, 13 par 4s, 5 par 3s)

Distance (yellow): 5582

Moly’s Gross score: 94.

Moly’s Ballater scorecard – 94 for only 25 Stableford points:(

57. Stonehaven. 1st Dec 2016

December 3, 2016 / Moly McMillan

A curate’s egg of a course with great views and some excellent par 3s

Round £37. Par 66. Value (out of 5) 2.5

Stonehaven golf course in Aberdeenshire sits atop a cliff on land called the Braes of Cowie just to the north of the seaside town of Stonehaven. The cliff top vantage provides for some outstanding views of the coastline, North sea and the town.

The open 1st hole at Stonehaven.

The course, founded in 1888, has a convoluted architecture influenced by 2 distinct lines; the east coast train line which goes directly through the course and the Highland Fault line (dividing Scotland from east to west). The Fault Line forms “The Gully” feature which dominates play on holes 13 and 15 where it has to be carried.

3rd green at Stonehave looking south towards the town.

The course is played on arable land and to the east of the train line, with 14 holes, it has no trees, whereas the 4 holes on the west of the train line has trees; the overall course feels typically parkland, with pretty generous fairways. On the east of the line, the major hazards are the cliff tops and the gully, which collectively impact about 6 holes, and these are the real challenge here. The remaining holes are fairly bland, with only few fairway bunkers.

The tough mid-iron par 3 14th, with green beside the cliff!

The tough mid-iron par 3 7th, with green beside the cliff!

Although the major design work was completed by 1897, the course is a designated James Braid “design”, as he and Archie Simpson, the Royal Aberdeen professional, are deemed to have planned improvements to the course, although I couldn’t find out what they are. An interesting design note, is the presence of “Hitler’s bunker” a crater hole between the first and second fairways, caused by, you’ve guessed it, a bomb during WWII.

8th at Stonehaven with Winter sun

The course is around 5000 yards, so distance is not the issue here. The feature holes are those where the cliffs and gully are in play. In particular the mid to long iron par 3 7th hole, requires a cool head to go to the heart of the green, and the long par 13th at 220 yards uphill over “The Gully” will need driver for all bar the long hitters. Note these were played as holes 14th and 5th on the winter card (see below).

Overall, play to keep the ball away from the cliffs and you’ll be rewarded. I did so, but my putting let me down on the day, although the greens were in excellent condition for the time of year. In fact the course was in all round good condition.

The typically small 18th green with church ruin and graveyard…perhaps an apt epitaph for some rounds here!

My only gripe with Stonehaven was how the website oversells the course as “The best value golf in the North-East of Scotland”. It is a really nice golf course, with great views, and is worth playing, but this self-declared “value” is a exaggeration in my opinion, which is a shame.

Some Facts

Course Type: Parkland

Par 66 (1 par 5, 10 par 4s, 7 par 3s)

Distance yards: 4458

Moly’s Gross Score: 86

Moly’s Stonehaven scorecard, 86 – note this is the winter card, which has a different layout.

Category: Aberdeen City and Shire (Page 2 of 3)

80. Torphins. 25 June 2018.

76. Meldrum House. 19 June 2018.

61. Ballater. 2nd Aug 2017.

57. Stonehaven. 1st Dec 2016

Recent Posts

Useful Links