Category: 9 holes (Page 1 of 13)

193. Maybole. 29 Apr 23.

October 22, 2026 / Moly McMillan

Maybole: a town that has never agreed on anything, including whether it needs a golf course.

Price Paid: £4 (winter rate, paid at the swimming pool over the road)
Current Price (2026): £8 GolfNow; £24 list (Golf South Ayrshire)
Value: 3/5 at £4 paid | 2.5/5 at £8 GolfNow | 1/5 at £24 list
Moly’s Score: 40 gross, 34 net, 17 Stableford points (9 holes)

Getting a consensus in Maybole has never been easy. Start with the name. A charter of 1192 calls the place Maybothel, which some read as Old English for a maiden’s house. Others prefer Gaelic: a plain with a cattle fold on it. The old folk called it Minnybole, which points to a moor instead. When the Ordnance Survey arrived in the 1850s, its surveyors dutifully listed the rival theories and dismissed one as purely fanciful. Nobody has settled it since.

Then there is the town’s most famous argument. In 1562 John Knox came to Carrick and was challenged by Quintin Kennedy, Abbot of Crossraguel, to debate the Mass. They met in the Provost’s house with forty witnesses apiece and argued for three days. Neither man won. The 1860 Encyclopaedia Britannica records that both claimed victory. That is Maybole in a sentence.

Which brings me to golf, and an argument the town has been having for a decade: does Maybole need a golf course?

The club was founded in 1905 on a course off the Dailly Road. It later moved into the Memorial Park, land the town bought to remember its Great War dead. In 1935 a storm lifted the pavilion off its foundations and smashed it. Visitors then paid sixpence a round and couldn’t play on Sundays. Closure threats came in 2016, 2018 and 2020. In February 2023 the club finally folded for “lack of support”, and the golf press mourned a 118-year-old institution.

I went looking to debunk the 118 years, and I couldn’t. Golf’s Missing Links headlines the club as 1905–2023, then says in its own text that it ceased to exist in 1923. Even the archive can’t reach a consensus. But its Golfer’s Handbook entries run unbroken from the 1930s to the 2000s, so 1923 is plainly a slip for 2023. The club’s age stands. The course is younger.

Fourteen months later, Carrick Speakers Golf Club folded too, after 35 years. That made two clubs gone from one nine-holer. The course carries on regardless as one of eight run by Golf South Ayrshire, and the local councillor insists there is no threat to it. A community company now wants the pavilion as a meeting space and e-bike store. That may be the future of the Scottish town course: still there, but no longer anybody’s club.

The Maybole Golf Club pavilion, shuttered since the club folded in February 2023. Green fees are now paid at the swimming pool across the road, and a community group has applied to turn the building into a meeting space and e-bike store.

I arrived ten weeks after the club folded, paid my £4 at the pool, and played alone. The course repays the effort. It is hilly and constantly undulating, with small greens. The par 3s are the real examination: the 3rd and 6th measure 198 and 219 yards off the yellows, a long way to a small target, and both cost me a shot. Footgolf shares the fairways, and dog walkers share everything else.

The tee markers deserve a paragraph of their own. Each hole has a yellow metal bin, hand-painted with its name and yardages. The 1st is “Railway”. Somebody took real care over these. The dog walkers have found another use for them.

**The 1st, “Railway”: hand-painted yardages on a metal tee bin. It doubles as a dog-bag bin, which is about as municipal as golf gets.**

The 3rd green looks back over the rooftops of the old Kennedy capital. The 5th climbs steadily to a green beneath the Maybole War Memorial, a reminder of why this park exists at all.

**Behind the 3rd green, Maybole’s slate roofs and church fall away down the hill. The green is small and sloping, typical of the course.**

**The 5th green beneath the Maybole War Memorial. The bunker is neatly raked, its edge less so: honest council maintenance.**

The conditioning is honest council standard: well-cut fairways, raked bunkers, and rough edges where the budget runs out. It is better than its South Ayrshire stablemate Dalmilling (Blog 192). I went round in 40 for 17 points, in 65 minutes, which on those greens felt fair.

**The 4th Green, showing the dovetailed Foot and Normal golf**

**From the 9th tee, the view back to the swimming pool, where you pay, and the town beyond. A lone dog walker is on duty.**

At £4 this is 3/5 value. Cheap is not the same as good value: there is no club, no clubhouse, and a course that is honest rather than memorable. At £8 on GolfNow it slips to 2.5/5. At the new £24 rack rate it is 1/5, because for that money you’d expect the clubhouse lights to be on.

Whether Maybole needs a golf course is a debate that, like Knox and the abbot, will probably end with both sides claiming victory. For £4, I’m happy to declare mine.

Facts:
Course Type: Parkland (hilly town course in the Memorial Park)
Par: 33 for 9 holes (6 par 4s, 3 par 3s); 66 played twice
Distance: 2,420 yards from the yellows (4,840 for 18)
Course Rating/Slope: 64.0 / 109 (yellow, 18 holes)
Course Quality: 2/5
Moly’s Gross Score: 40 (34 net, 17 Stableford points)

**Moly’s card, 40 shots took 65 minutes!**

186. Broadlees Par 3. 25 Mar 2023

June 14, 2026 / Moly McMillan

Scotland’s first synthetic greens course, probably.

Price: £8. Par 27. Value: 4/5.

Moly’s Score: 31 (+4)

The backstory is in Blog 185, the main Broadlees course. In summary, since 2004, Robert and Barbara Anderson have built a diverse golf operation – range, 9-hole course, crazy golf, footgolf, academy, café and Santa’s grotto – to compete in an area stocked with golfing alternatives, many of them subsidised.

In 2021, they added something possibly unique in Scotland: a 9-hole par 3 course with synthetic greens and tees, playable every day of the year regardless of weather or ground conditions. The commercial reasoning is sound: a course needing no greenkeeping on its playing surfaces, generating income in January.

**The first (97 yards) with the startlingly green synthetic surface immediately apparent against the March gloom. You are not playing a normal golf course.**

From the start the scene is stripped back entirely with open ground, single windswept tree, and a synthetic “green” looking like a piece of discarded carpet. Not aesthetic, but very interesting, with the graves of golfing Architects stirring?

Synthetic tees matter commercially as much as the greens, as grass par 3 tees are brutally punished and need constant repair, reseeding, levelling and divot mix. The cost of upkeep of mats is negligible, plus they play consistently.

*Hole 3* from *elevated tee. The two wind turbines are a constant presence*.

Holes range from 85 to 138 yards, so this is great wedge practice. They are not architecturally interesting in any way. But the holes have several water hazards to contend with.

*The fourth green* with synthetic pile; dense, uniform with its own playing logic.

The key question is “how do the greens play?”. The answer is situational. In wet March conditions the green surrounds were too soft for a chip and run approach. The only option was to fly the ball onto the front of the green and allow it to release. The surface bounces more than ‘checks’ on full shots, so that requires careful judgment. Land too deep into the green and the ball runs through; land short and it stops on wet grass short.

Short chips around the green, played softly, were a different matter — the synthetic pile had enough give to generate some check, certainly more than expected. A useful discovery, though it came too late on the card to rescue early bogeys. On the greens themselves the ball rolled true, although breaking differently from a grass surface.

*The 9th (91 yards), looking towards the Broadlees clubhouse*, with cafe, range, and main course off to the right.

I shot 31 gross, four over par. On the two holes where I holed from outside ten feet I correctly read that the ball would not break as much as expected. It was an education. I’m sure regular players hole lots of putts.

At £8 for nine holes (2023) this is great ‘novelty’ value. I would think there is a commercial opportunity to price a combined fee with 9 holes on this course and 9 holes on the main Broadlees course.

Value: 4/5, to play Scotland’s first and possibly only synthetic greens course

Facts:

Course type: Par 3, synthetic tees and greens

Par 27 . Distance: 972 yards.

Moly’s Gross Score: 31 (+4)

185. Broadlees. 25 Mar 2023.

June 12, 2026 / Moly McMillan

If a farmer builds a golf course, this is what might be par.

Price: £16. Par 36. CR 69.0, Slope 119.

Value: 3.5 / 5.

Moly’s Score: 45

In 1987, the UK Government launched the Farm Diversification Grant Scheme, to incentivise farmers to diversify; by the early 1990s courses began sprouting at a rate that may have startled Old Tom Morris. My own club, Isle of Wedmore in Somerset, was built in 1992 on Lineage Farm by Ken Abraham, using a standard hymn sheet – rolling agricultural land, modest construction budget, an unfussy layout, and a prayer that golfers would cover the mortgage.

**“Anderson’s Garage” the aptly named first hole,** **par 4, surrounded by Farmer’s fields**

Robert and Barbara Anderson did the same in 2004, converting their South Lanarkshire farm into the Broadlees Golf operation; range, 9-hole course, crazy golf, footgolf, academy, cafe and in 2021 a second very unusual addition (covered in Blog 186). They self-confidently named the course’s address “Anderson” Drive, Chapelton, after themselves!

The workmanlike hole names also gives insight to the Andersons; ‘Anderson’s Garage’, ‘Gas Works’, ‘Worker’s Way’, ‘Out the Moss’, ‘Old Road’ and ‘Five Acre’. The ‘Powmillon’ burn (hole 4) runs through well-heeled Strathaven a few miles to the south-east, whose own Golf Club has more bourgeois hole names.

*The Broadlees free laminated course guid*e, that much grander clubs could learn from.

The Andersons display good commercial instincts, no more so than with the ‘free’ laminated course guide (see above). For a pay-and-play operation of this scale it is more than you expect, and much better than many established member clubs that charge several times the greenfee.

**A poignant fifth hole spot with tractor seats (?) repurposed for rest — an honest summary of Broadlees origins. The memorial bench commemorates John Anderson.**

What you might get when a farmer builds a golf course on a limited budget is, I think, what you get here. The bones are reasonable at around 3000 yards, a par 36 with two par fives and two par threes. The par-five 4th (Powmillion, 479 yards) and the par-five 7th (Over the Burn, 456 yards) give the round depth. Water features on some holes, including a pond at the 2nd and a burn that winds its way around the 7th green, retained by a rustic timber revetted bank. Bunkering is sufficient, but was unraked when I played.

**The limited framing developed is shown here at the 2nd hole, ‘Gas Works’, a short par 4.**

The central challenge with designing a course on open farmland, such as Broadlees, is framing. Well framed holes visually present a picture using trees, contour, rough, bunkers, water and elevation. This skill is epitomised by the Camoufleur Alister MacKenzie, whose work can be seen at Pitreavie (Dunfermline) see blog 150. At Broadlees, fairways unceremoniously bleed into rough. The trees planted are still young; scrub and rough areas are unformed; the contours, while present, have not yet sharpened. I hope the Anderson family get to see Broadlees mature.

**The 7th green (Over the Burn, par 5, 456 yards), its rustic timber-revetted bank is the course’s most marked piece of construction.**

The greens are the strongest element. True, consistent and well-presented on a late-March morning when much of the course was still very wet. However, the claim that they rank among the finest putting surfaces in Lanarkshire is bold, and nowhere near the truth in my opinion.

The 6th, ‘*Out the Moss’ (par 4, 290 yards). A typical hole on Broadlees*

The two wind turbines deserve a mention as they are visible from most holes and dominate the final green. They present a reminder that Broadlees is a commercial enterprise built by farmers who needed multiple revenue streams from a single property. The turbines, golf course, cafe, Santa’s grotto. Each a response to the same challenge – making a small rural business pay in a Scottish golf landscape where established member clubs and council-owned courses provide stiff, and often quietly subsidised, competition.

At £16 for nine holes, Broadlees is cheap, and relatively good value. Within a few miles, South Lanarkshire golfers have many choices, so Broadlees needs to keep well below the competition fees, certainly until the course matures.

The Andersons, however, were not finished. In 2021, they added a second course — and this one was genuinely unlike anything else in Scotland. See Blog 186 to find out more.

Value: 3.5 / 5. The Andersons have built something from nothing and kept adding to it for twenty years. That deserves acknowledgement. But a golf course is not only measured by the effort that went into building it. The framing will come. It just wasn’t there yet. But at the price it’s good value.

Facts:

Course type: Parkland/Pasture

Par 36 (2 par 5s, 5 par 4s, 2 par 3s)

Distance: 2,954 yards (yellow tees)

Moly’s Gross Score: 45 (9 holes)

See also: Blog 186 — Broadlees Par 3 Golf Course

**Moly’s card. Level 5s, I hit the ball pretty steady.**

183. Mearns Castle. 24 Mar 23.

June 10, 2026 / Moly McMillan

“Most scenic and challenging in the area.” An exaggerated claim by the Academy.

Round £10 (GolfNow Hot Deal, now £20). Par 31. Value 2/5.

Moly’s Score – 40

There is a real Mearns Castle about half a mile from the golf course, built in 1449 by Lord Herbert Maxwell. The same Maxwell family whose descendants would eventually own Southerness on the Solway Firth, reviewed in Blog 164, a course that justifies the word “scenic” more than anything I encountered here.

**The actual nearby ‘Mearns Castle’, a 15th century Maxwell tower house, which the course takes its name. I wonder if Satnav ever gets this confused with the course.**

The castle has, as far as I can establish, no connection whatsoever to the golf academy except proximity and, one suspects, the marketable romance of a medieval tower.

The golf academy is a substantial operation with Toptracer range, tuition, café, fitness studio, nail salon, and a massage therapist! More of a leisure complex with a 9-hole course attached. Nothing wrong with that, but problems begin when the website describes that course as “one of the most scenic and challenging courses in the area.”

I played it on 24 March 2023, via a GolfNow Hot Deal, for £10. It was waterlogged. It should have been closed.

**How could you allow play with fairways like this in several places. Sometimes short term economics doesn’t make sense.** **One never knows if a Blogger will come along!**

The course occupies pleasant enough parkland on the southern fringes of Newton Mearns, the well heeled commuter town south of Glasgow. The 1st offered an early introduction to the course’s style: there is a hidden fairway ditch ready to swallow a ball without warning. This was one of the very few “challenging” features though.

The course had minimal fairway bunkering. However the greens were surprisingly good surfaces, so well done to the greenkeepers. It is the one positive comment I can offer.

**The greens were redeeming, a benefit for players learning the game. Here at the 4th.**

The course website mentioned “continued investment in drainage and course improvements.” This is a tacit acknowledgement that drainage was a problem, which again raises the question why the course was open. A course that quietly admits its drainage issues while remaining open in March when waterlogged is providing very poor value, even at £10.

**The was the typically bland approach view, here at the 5th hole, with the building ruins on the left being one of the very few interesting features.**

The list price is now £20 for nine holes, I paid £10 on a Hot Deal. But golf on a course that should have been closed, is not good value at any price. The marketing overclaim tips it further – a course that sets expectations it cannot meet is doing its visitors a disservice.

Facts:

Course Type: Parkland

Par 31 (9 holes)

Moly’s Gross Score: 40 (net par)

Round: £10 (GolfNow Hot Deal). List price £20 (9 holes).

Value: 2/5

Category: 9 holes (Page 1 of 13)

193. Maybole. 29 Apr 23.

186. Broadlees Par 3. 25 Mar 2023

185. Broadlees. 25 Mar 2023.

183. Mearns Castle. 24 Mar 23.

Recent Posts

Useful Links