Scotland Golf Bible

A guide to green fee value for money

215. Hazlehead 9 hole course. 8 Aug 23.

Per hole, this ‘field’ costs the same as the MacKenzie. Come on, Aberdeen Council.

Price Paid: £15, paid direct at the starter’s box (2023 adult rate, no concession)
Current Price (2026): £17.80 summer list (Apr to Oct); £11.50 winter list; GolfNow £13
Value: 2/5 at £15 paid / 2/5 at £13 GolfNow / 1.5/5 at £17.80 summer list; 2/5 at £11.50 winter list
Moly’s Score: 46 gross, 39 net (9-hole handicap 7)

I had played the Hazlehead MacKenzie (Blog 214) in the morning and the Hazlehead Pines (Blog 151) the summer before, so the 9-holer completed the set. Hazlehead 9 Hole is the third and smallest of the three courses in Hazlehead Park, about four miles west of Aberdeen city centre. I played alone.

The 3rd green, at the end of a 217-yard par 3, with Aberdeen and the North Sea on the horizon. The view is the best thing on the course.

Three different outfits run Hazlehead. The pro runs his own shop. Hazlehead Golf Club looks after its members and does the food. The courses belong to the council and are run by Sport Aberdeen, which is why the 9-holer has its own starter’s box and its own phone number. The man in the box was the best part of the visit: friendly, helpful, but with no way of giving me a concession. Visitor fees come in three flavours: adult, junior and student. Pensioners pay the adult rate.

The 1st, Wish/Well, 333 yards. Sport Aberdeen calls it “wide fairways”. My notes call it a field with greens.

This is the odd part. Golf Aberdeen charges the same for all its 18-hole courses, which I praised in Blog 151 because it made the Pines good value. The 9-holer is simply half that rate. That morning I’d paid £15 on GolfNow for the MacKenzie, against a £30 list price, and the 9-holer cost the other £15 at the starter’s box. So three very different courses at Hazlehead cost exactly the same per hole. In summer 2026 it’s £35.60 for 18 holes on either the MacKenzie or the Pines and £17.80 here, which is also the MacKenzie’s twilight rate. On a summer evening, the same money buys you 18 holes of MacKenzie or nine holes of this. Whoever set the fees divided by two and stopped there.

The 7th tee, Hillock. A plastic marker, a broken tee and not much grass, ahead of a 231-yard par 3 that no beginner will reach.

Sport Aberdeen pitches the course at beginners, golfers short of time, and anyone wanting to practise. That’s fair. The fairways are wide and there’s hardly any rough. The tees were abysmal, as tired as the ones I’d found on the Pines (Blog 151), so it isn’t just one course at Hazlehead with that problem. The greens were good, and that’s a genuine compliment. The par 3s are not beginners’ holes, though. Farm is 217 yards and Hillock is 231. Sahara, the 503-yard 6th, is the one hole with a name it has to live up to.

The 4th green, tucked under the pines. It’s the prettiest corner of the course, and the greens were the best thing about the golf.

The course web page adds some heritage: golf, it says, has been played “in this area since 1661”. The 1661 record is of golf on the town links between the Don and the Dee, on the beach, four miles east. Sport Aberdeen uses the same line on its Kings Links page, where it is at least close to true.

The 8th green, Roadside. On my own, so this is the proof I was there.

Nobody seems to know who designed it or when it opened. A trade magazine apparently dating from 1971 reports Aberdeen planning “a new 18 and two new nines [sic] at Hazlehead and Balnagask”, which probably puts it in the 1970s. That leaves it about 300 years short of the “since 1661” on its web page.

The Pines next door was actually a nine-holer itself until it was extended in the 1970s. This one is still a nine-holer. Priced as what it is, a council beginners’ course, it would be a useful city asset. Priced per hole the same as the MacKenzie, it’s 2/5 value.

Facts:
Course Type: Parkland
Par: 35 (1 par 5, 6 par 4s, 2 par 3s)
Distance: 2,770 yards
Course Rating / Slope: 33.2 / 105
Course Quality: 2/5
Moly’s Gross Score: 46

214. Hazlehead MacKenzie. 8 Aug 23.

Promised a Sunningdale, Aberdeen sacked MacKenzie, let the Parks Department finish the job, then named the course after him. At times, truth is beautiful.

Price Paid: £15 (GolfNow; list price £30 in 2023)
Current Price (2026): £35.60 summer list; £17.80 twilight; £22 winter list; £25 GolfNow (winter)
Value Rating: 5/5 at £15 / 5/5 at £25 current GolfNow / 4.5/5 at £35.60 summer list
Moly’s Score: 99 gross; net 84; 24 Stableford points (playing handicap 15)

Fran hits her approach on the 2nd between walls of pine, larch and beech. There’s not a house in sight, and you’re four miles from the centre of Aberdeen.

The MacKenzie Championship Course sits in Hazlehead Park, about four miles west of the city centre in the Aberdeen City council area. In 1319 Robert the Bruce feued the royal Stocket Forest, Hazlehead included, to the burgh. From 1551 the town feued it out in turn, and the land drifted into private estates before the council bought Hazlehead back in 1920 for £40,000. Then it hired the finest golf architect alive and fell out with him.

The opening tee shot runs down a corridor of conifers. The sign says “MacKenzie Championship Course”, a name Aberdeen only got round to in 2015.

I covered MacKenzie the man in Pitreavie (Blog 150): the camouflage, the principles, the “dead ground”. His Hazlehead story is much less flattering. He started advising the council in 1922 and told them to expect something like Sunningdale, on a budget of £8,000. By the summer of 1926 the project was late and over budget, due to unforeseen ground conditions, and MacKenzie was venting at the council in the Press and Journal and offering to finish the job for nothing.

Me on the 5th, the first par 3, at 169 yards: one big bunker short of a large green. Simple, and it works. Practice swing also works.

The council declined and paid him off. Only ten of his holes had been built. The Links and Parks Superintendent, a Mr Clark, was told to finish the rest as cheaply and as quickly as possible, and he laid them out in the open meadows beside the wood. The course opened in July 1927, two years late and about £10,000 over budget. Some 5,000 people watched J.H. Taylor play the exhibition match. The Lord Provost’s speech didn’t mention MacKenzie, who stayed away.

The 6th tee (SI 3), squeezed between beech and rowan. Note the worn teeing ground. I took 8.

Eighty-eight years later, in 2015, the council renamed its No 1 course in his honour, and the course turns 100 in 2027. Sport Aberdeen now says the course “still retains the architect’s basic design”. “Basic” is doing a lot of work in that sentence.

The 8th green: a rare cluster of three bunkers, with Fran walking up under a typically Aberdonian sky.

So what did I find? The woodland holes are genuinely good. The greens are very large and were in good condition, and the bunkering is economical: usually one dominant greenside bunker rather than a scattering. Among the pines I kept thinking of Blairgowrie’s Rosemount (Blog 176), where MacKenzie also had a hand, and Ladybank (Blog 160). But much of the course is flat, and the holes have less variety than the name on the sign leads you to expect. Now I know why: that’s what meadow golf on a council budget looks like. The tees and some of the bunkers could be better too.

From the 10th green the view opens east over the city towards the sea.

I partnered Fran and I played very poorly. The shank made an appearance, three balls were lost, and those enormous greens extracted four three-putts. The 6th and 7th, two of the hardest holes on the front nine, cost me two snowmen. Final tally: 99 gross and 24 points.

Colin Nelson, the PGA professional at Hazlehead, told me the Golf Aberdeen membership was “the best value golf in the world”. He’d never heard of South Ayrshire’s season ticket, so I did the comparison for him. In 2023 the five-day senior subscription was £19 a month. Today the five-day adult ticket is £27.50 a month (£330 a year) for five courses, with 25% off for Aberdeen residents of state pension age. Golf South Ayrshire’s five-day ticket for 2026/27 costs £495 for eight courses. “The world” is beyond my research budget, but within Scotland Colin may well be right.

Fran on the 14th green. The bunker in front is deep and its sand a little tired.

Does it matter that MacKenzie didn’t finish the job? To the golf, less than you’d think: a good hole is a good hole, whoever drew it. To our perception of it, it matters a great deal. Put “MacKenzie” on the sign and we arrive expecting a masterpiece, and too often we find one, because we were told to. I’m no different: I walked those pine-lined holes thinking of Blairgowrie. We’re all sheep at times.

The 18th, with Colin Nelson’s pro shop, “MacKenzie’s”, on the left and the Hazlehead Golf Club clubhouse beside it.

Strip away the myth and this is a good council parkland course: ten holes with a famous pedigree, eight of municipal thrift, and fine greens throughout. At £15 that’s 5/5 value. GolfNow’s £25 winter rate still earns 5/5, though the council’s own winter fee is £22, so for once it pays to book direct. The £35.60 summer rate is 4.5/5, and the £17.80 twilight rate is a steal. Would I go back? Yes, with fewer shanks, and without the halo.

Facts:
Course Type: Parkland (woodland)
Par: 70 (2 par 5s, 12 par 4s, 4 par 3s)
Distance: 5,963 yards (yellow tees)
Course Rating / Slope: 69.3 / 124
Course Quality: 4/5
Moly’s Gross Score: 99

In good conditions, the ‘MacKenzie’ course took my game apart. Blame the player, not the architect..

213. Westhill. 7 Aug 23.

The Power of Facebook.

Price Paid: Member’s guest
Current Price (2025): £40 summer visitor; £20 winter visitor.
Value Rating: 4.5/5 at £40 summer / 5/5 at £20 winter / GolfNow 5/5 at ~£25
Moly’s Score: 90 gross; 77 nett; 30 Stableford points (playing handicap 13)

Neil Mair (right), our host, and me on the 3rd, with lower Deeside spread out behind. Note the rain.

I’m not the only one. There is a fraternity of golfers trying to play every course in Scotland, several loosely linked through Facebook and that’s how I met Neil Mair who had invited Fran and me for a game at his home club. He also introduced me to Simon Tough who got us onto Murcar (Blog 218) later the same week. Thank you, Neil, for your generous spirt.

Rain sweeping in across the 2nd tee. The masts on the skyline handle microwave links between Aberdeen and the North Sea platforms, so even the view here is an oil-town view.

Westhill Golf Club sits on the slopes above Westhill just eight miles west of Aberdeen city centre. The town is younger than many of its residents. It was fields until a solicitor proposed a new settlement in 1963, and the first houses went up in 1968. The oil boom then filled them with young families. The course opened in 1976, alongside the Westhill Inn. The club itself was formed at the Inn on 5 October 1977, by 60 people.

The par four 7th: immaculate teeing ground and mature trees, at the toughest hole on the front nine. It’s in better condition than many courses charging twice the price.

The pedigree of this course design is down to Charles Lawrie, of Cotton Pennink Lawrie, who also designed Woburn’s Duke’s course. Lawrie died in August 1976, more than a year before the club was formed. Westhill must have been among his last drawings.

Neil shows how it should be done using his low handicap swing into the 8th, a 428-yard par 4.

The undulating parkland course is 5,813 yards and par 70 from the whites. Driving is mostly generous. The greens were excellent and the tees good, but the fairways tilt and roll, so you get several uneven lies. The bunkers are shallow and the weakest part of the course. The back nine is noticeably harder, built around the 441-yard 14th, which is stroke index 1. In 2014 the club turned the 18th from a hard uphill par 4 into a par 5, but only from the whites. From the yellows it is still a 369-yard par 4.

The 4th: ball in tree, red mark on trunk, driver in the branches. The lichen suggests the air is cleaner than my golf.

The club struck me as progressive but sensible about it. To speed up play, some tree areas are now marked as red penalty areas. On the 4th I found one of these trees, and my ball stayed up in the branches. I reached up and played my shortest ever drive. I took a 7, and I’m still not sure whether a ball stuck in a tree counts as being in the penalty area.

A first and hopefully last tree shot!
Fran on the short 6th, with the pond, the pines and a narrow way through to the green.

At £40 in summer, Westhill is good value: excellent greens, exceptional views and a well-run club. The bunkers and the sidehill lies are what stop it scoring higher. The £20 winter rate is a bargain if you catch a dry day. I’d go back.

The 11th green: true putting surface, steep surrounds. Miss it and you’ll pay, as my 5 shows.

The clubhouse has a big view of its own. Neil told me that after the club handed its catering to an outside operator, bar takings trebled. Clubs worrying about their survival should take note.

Facts:
Course Type: Parkland (hilly)
Par: 70 (3 par 5s, 10 par 4s, 5 par 3s)
Distance: 5,813 yards (white tees)
Course Rating / Slope: 68.3 / 123
Course Quality: 3/5
Moly’s Gross Score: 90

30 points is always my measure of a good round when playing a course for the first time.

212. Ranfurly Castle. 26 Jun 23.

The castle club that left its castle behind, and paid for its new course by selling building plots. Property-funded golf is nothing new.

Price Paid: £63, society rate (the “Cavens” package: coffee and a roll, 18 holes and a two-course meal)
Current Price (2026): Current Price (2026): £55 visitor green fee + £3 Scottish Golf booking fee = £58 (winter weekday). Green fees not published; 2027 rates not yet bookable.
Value: 4/5 at £63 with food / 3/5 at current list
Moly’s Score: 95 gross, net 81, 30 Stableford points

The 8th, Rowans, stroke index 1. You drive from a raised tee down into a moorland bowl of bracken and heather, with Misty Law on the skyline. Pure Renfrewshire moorland.

Ranfurly Castle is not on Ranfurly Castle’s golf course. The ruin is a 15th-century tower built by the ancestors of John Knox, the leader of the Scottish Reformation. It actually stands near the 17th fairway of Old Ranfurly, the other golf club in Bridge of Weir, a Renfrewshire village, 15 miles west of Glasgow. The club was founded beside the castle in 1889, but moved out in 1904 after a row over the lease and took the name with it. A new club, Old Ranfurly, formed in 1905 on the ground left behind. So the ‘Old’ club is the younger one and has the castle. Confused?

Birdie chance at the short par three 5th?

In December 1903 the members bought Clevans and East Barnbeth farms, totalling 220 acres, for £6,500. The Bridge of Weir Thistle club, which had been playing nine holes at Clevans, was promptly squeezed out to Auchensale. Perhaps evicted tenants make the most efficient landlords? Both farm names survive as hole names. James Cuthbertson, the captain who opened the new course, recorded in a 1950 letter now framed in the clubhouse that the land where the 1st and 18th now run was under “a rather miserable crop of turnips and potatoes”. Part of the 3rd was swamp. The present 14th was the old Barmufflock Dam, “an impassable morass”. It took 80 men and women, with 17 horses and carts, to clear the ground. The condition of the course is thankfully much improved.

The 1904 plan of “Proposed Feus at New Golf Course”. The fairway is the middle of the sandwich, with building plots for villas on both sides.

Then the clever part. The committee reckoned the land along both sides of the new course was worth not £30 an acre but £400 to £500. So they feued it (the Scottish system of granting land in perpetuity for a fixed annual payment, the feu duty) for villas, raised £2,684 from feu duties, and had the members lend another £6,000 in debentures. In other words, an Edwardian golf club funded its new course with a housing scheme. Modern developers are not inventing any wheels.

Frank putts out on the 2nd, top of the climb, with the Clyde valley and Glasgow spread out behind and a shower drifting across the horizon.

The new course, laid out by Andrew Kirkaldy, opened in 1905. James Braid made recommendations in 1923, only some of which were adopted.But the current course is an intriguing 1930 rebuild. The club rejected two routings by Harry Colt, arguably the leading architect of his day, in favour of one by its own captain, James Robson. It then paid Colt to design the holes on Robson’s plan and oversee the work. Ranfurly members clearly knew their own minds.

Brian at the difficult par five 3rd hole.

It is a tough course. The first two holes climb steeply onto a moorland plateau. Fourteen holes are played up there, and the last two bring you back down. I played with my Apex Scotland buddies, Frank, Gordon and Brian, first seen at Longniddry (Blog 128). The wind blew hard on the plateau, the rough was thick, and the greens slope steeply and come in every size. Worse, there are several blind tee shots. Our round took four hours 45 minutes. The slope rating from the yellows is a modest 121. We didn’t find it modest.

Lining up a birdie putt at the Wee De’il, the 114-yard 5th, with the Arrochar Alps on the skyline.

The views are wonderful. On the 2nd and 11th you look east over Glasgow, and on the 5th north to the Arrochar Alps. The conifers that frame the 9th and 12th rival Braid’s arboretum at East Ren (Blog 169). The 14th, Barmufflock, is my favourite piece of history on the course. Cuthbertson’s impassable morass is now a well-bunkered par 3 in a hollow, though the matting across the approach suggests the morass hasn’t entirely given up.

The 14th, Barmufflock. In 1904 it was the old dam and “an impassable morass”. Today it’s a 178-yard par 3, with matting to remind you what lies underneath.

The clubhouse walls are worth a look too. A framed photograph shows Lady Spiers of Elderslie opening the Ladies’ Golf Club clubhouse in October 1897. The Bridge of Weir and Ranfurly Ladies’ club was formed in 1896 and was a separate club, with its own nine holes and 270 members by 1914. The castle club itself didn’t absorb a ladies’ section until around the Second World War. So the Victorian ladies were ahead of the men, if not exactly welcomed by them.

Lady Spiers of Elderslie opens the Ladies’ Golf Club, 16 October 1897. The hats alone deserve a blog.

A neighbouring panel claims that Lady Anne Spiers’s Houston lacemakers made the canopy over Queen Victoria’s throne at the 1897 Diamond Jubilee “ceremony in Westminster Abbey”. It’s a lovely story, but the details don’t hold up. The 1897 Diamond Jubilee service was held outdoors on the steps of St Paul’s, with the Queen in her carriage because she could no longer manage the steps. The Westminster Abbey service was the Golden Jubilee, ten years earlier. Either the lace went to 1887, or the story has improved with retelling.

Gordon at the drivable par four 4th.

A photograph on the same wall fares better. It shows Sandy Herd watching Willie Fernie putt on “the 18th green at Ranfurly Castle” in July 1895. I went looking for a flaw and found none. The club had stretched to eighteen holes in 1894 and opened them in 1895 with a professional foursome of J. H. Taylor, Herd, Andrew Kirkaldy and Fernie. The caption is right. It’s just that the green in the photo now belongs to Old Ranfurly.

Sandy Herd watches Willie Fernie putt on the 18th green, July 1895.

On value: £63 bought coffee, a roll, eighteen holes on a genuinely good moorland course and a two-course meal. That’s 4/5. The clubhouse is J. A. Campbell’s 1905 Arts and Crafts building with its clock tower, now B-listed. He won the commission in competition, and the club promptly cut his £4,750 estimate to £3,500. Ranfurly members have always known the value of money. It’s a fine place to eat the meal.

Facts:
Course Type: Moorland
Par: 70 (1 par 5, 14 par 4s, 3 par 3s)
Distance: 5,942 yards (yellow)
Course Rating / Slope: 69.1 / 121
Course Quality: 4/5
Moly’s Gross Score: 95

five ‘blobs’. A bearable Stableford but poor stroke play card.

« Older posts

© 2026 Scotland Golf Bible

Theme by Anders Noren — Up ↑